Search eceee proceedings
The rise of sufficiency in the French energy debate: a comparative analysis of scenarios
Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption: less is more?
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Authors:
Edouard Toulouse, Association négaWatt, France
Albane Gaspard, ADEME, France
Abstract
The public debate on energy has been fierce in France in the months preceding national elections in 2022, due to the urgent need to prepare the country’s energy future. Interestingly, sufficiency has become an increasingly discussed topic, as a solution to achieve climate neutrality and reduce the constraints on the energy supply system.
One reason for this is the publication of several long-term energy scenarios from different institutions and organisations including some consideration of sufficiency. This has been a first time and has contributed to popularise the concept in the media and public opinion. However, has sufficiency been approached and modelled in a similar or different ways in these scenarios?
In this paper, we propose a comparative analysis of four of these scenarios: the 2050 négaWatt scenario, the ‘Energy Futures 2050’ exercise from RTE (national electricity grid authority), and two of the four climate neutrality scenarios released by ADEME (national agency for ecological transition). We investigate how these studies have been framed, look at methodological aspects to set sufficiency assumptions until 2050, and discuss the results. Last, we provide an overview of how these scenarios have been received and how far they have influenced decision makers.
This comparative analysis allows to better understand the methodological similarities, innovations, and limits of the scenarios. It also helps understanding how such sufficiency-based scenarios can contribute to the public debate process.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 1-086-22_Toulouse_pres.pdf
Download this paper as pdf: 1-086-22_Toulouse.pdf
Panels of
1. Dynamics of consumption: less is more?
2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies
3. Policy, finance and governance
4. Monitoring and evaluation for a wise, just and inclusive transition
5. Towards sustainable and resilient communities
6. Energy-efficient and low-carbon mobility for all
7. Policies and programmes for better buildings
8. Innovations in products, systems and building technologies


