Search eceee proceedings

A fair share of energy savings for energy poor households

Panel: 2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Louise Sunderland, RAP and Independent, United Kingdom
Samuel Thomas, Regulatory Assistance Project

Abstract

Energy efficiency is the most cost effective, long-term solution to energy poverty. Article 7 (now Article 8) of the Energy Efficiency Directive (EED) is the most important of all European energy efficiency policies; it delivers 50% of the savings needed to achieve the Union energy efficiency target. In the recast of the EED, released in July 2021 and currently under negotiation, the European Commission (EC) has proposed that Member States dedicate a share of the energy savings to be achieved “among people affected by energy poverty, vulnerable customers and, where applicable, people living in social housing.” The proposal also increases the annual energy savings obligation target from 0.8% to 1.5% from 2024.

This poster explores the proposals and issues for implementation. The EC proposes that the national ringfences are based on the share of the population in energy poverty reported in National Energy and Climate Plans but very few include this assessment. Alternatively, the ringfence is calculated by taking the average of three Eurostat indicators. The resulting ringfences range from 2.6% in Sweden to almost 23% in Bulgaria. The European Parliament Rapporteur has proposed an alternative calculation which increases the ringfences for almost all countries, with a range of 5.5% and 23%.

What would this mean for countries adapting their national energy savings policies to deliver to energy poor households? The poster draws on experience of countries that have already made provision for energy poor households. In particular, three countries – France, Ireland the UK - have dedicated between 5% and 10% of their Energy Efficiency Obligation Schemes (EEOS) to low-income or energy poor households. EEOSs are a useful lens as they are the most important single policy measure for compliance with Article 7 (now 8), used in 16 Member States, delivering an aggregate 35% of all reported savings. Lessons on energy poverty support through EEOSs is collated from two Horizon 2020 projects SocialWatt and ENSMOV.

First, a ringfence is essential to guarantee policy impact. Five countries incentivise the delivery of savings in target households by administratively increasing the value of the savings rather than ringfencing a share. The uplift alone has been insufficient to overcome the barriers and costs to delivery in the target group. The uplift in Austria (2015-2020) resulted in only 0.66% of savings in the target group. In Ireland the buyout price for energy savings – a proxy for the cost of the savings – in energy poor households is 15 times higher than in the non-residential sector and over four times higher than other residential savings, illustrating the cost barrier.

Second, targeting support does not rely on a national definition of energy poverty. France, Ireland and the UK all have an energy poverty definition but many countries do not. In practice, proxies are used to define eligibility not a full assessment of energy poverty status under the national definition. Proxies used include income status or access to ‘passport benefits’, age, low home energy performance or location, eg areas of deprivation.

Third, delivering just the most cost-effective savings – a principle that underpins many energy efficiency programmes - is not the most effective approach for social impact. Energy poor households often need a more complete set of advice, insulation and heating measures. Given the high barriers to and costs of engagement, delivering single or incomplete sets of measures makes poor use of the engagement opportunity. Creative partnerships of utilities, local authorities, social organisations and technology providers can reach more households with a more complete set of support. Experience from France illustrates the value in combining national and local support - the EEOS support and uplift, combined with other national and local funding streams has resulted in more savings for low-income households than the ringfence requires.

Downloads

Download this display (photo) as pdf: 2-226-22-displayphoto.pdf