Search eceee proceedings

Beyond energy efficiency: do consumers care about life-cycle properties of household appliances?

Panel: 2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Joachim Schleich, Grenoble Ecole de Management, France
Antoine Durand, Fraunhofer ISI, Germany
Corinne Faure, Grenoble Ecole de Management, France
Marie-Charlotte Guetlein, Grenoble Ecole de Management, France
Mark Olsthoorn, Grenoble Ecole de Management, France

Abstract

In the EU, past environmental regulation for household appliances has focused on energy use during usage, such as minimum energy performance standards or energy labels. To achieve EU commitments to become climate-neutral by 2050, recent policy efforts such as the new Battery Regulation and the revised Ecodesign Directive (Sustainable Product Initiative) are broadening the scope of requirements beyond the usage phase and cover lifecycle emissions. In parallel, many companies pledge to decarbonize their value chain by 2050. Previous literature includes engineer-ing-based studies analyzing energy use or emissions at different lifecycle phases of appliances. Socio-economic studies have investigated consumer valuation of energy use during the usage phase. Yet, little is known about consumer preferences for energy use during the production phase of appliances and for other lifecycle characteristics.

In this paper, we elicit individual preferences for lifecycle properties of large household applianc-es, in particular for production-related energy use. We also explore heterogeneity in preferences for various lifecycle properties of appliances. To this end, we employ a representative household survey among the adult population in Germany to study individual preferences for energy-related attributes of household refrigerating appliances. First, we analyze data from a discrete choice experiment on refrigerator purchase; we find that on average, participants value the highest en-ergy class, dislike much higher energy use for production and distribution, and prefer refrigerators with larger volume, longer warranty periods, and higher customer rating. Second, we elicit partici-pants' preferences for information about the energy use that is related to the manufacturing of large household appliances: About 20 percent of participants strongly agree that there should be a label for household appliances indicating the energy use necessary to manufacture them. Third, we investigate to which extent participants consider different lifecycle-related criteria when pur-chasing such appliances. Therefore, we asked participants to indicate how much they typically consider these criteria when making purchase decisions using a five-point rating scale ranging from ‘no consideration’ to ‘a lot of consideration’. We find that more than half the participants pay a lot of consideration to durability, but only around 15% pay a lot of consideration to envi-ronmentally-friendly materials, recyclability, and energy use necessary to manufacture the appli-ance. To explore the relation of participant preferences for these lifecycle criteria, we estimate multivariate statistical models which include socio-demographic information, environmental and time preferences, and an energy literacy score as covariates. The findings provide evidence that women, older participants (for durability only), less educated participants, participants living in an urban area, participants with higher environmental identity, more patient participants and partici-pants with a higher energy literacy score (for durability only) value lifecycle criteria higher. In comparison, we find no evidence that income or being an owner of the building rather than a tenant explain the preferences for lifecycle criteria.

Our findings also have implications for policy-making. A label on lifecycle properties should not only include information on usage and production-related energy use but also on other lifecycle properties. For production-related energy use it might be sufficient to use only a few categories to distinguish the products. Information about lifecycle properties of appliances should target wom-en, older people, people with below average education, and urban households. Finally, improving energy literacy would lead to a higher share of the adult population to strongly consider durability when purchasing an appliance.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 2-049-22_Schleich_pres.pdf