Search eceee proceedings

Energy efficiency first? The roles of energy efficiency for the decarbonisation of buildings

Panel: 2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Antoine Levesque, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Germany
Robin Krekeler, Potsdam Institut für Klimafolgenforschung
Sebastian Osorio, Potsdam Institut für Klimafolgenforschung
Michael Pahle, Potsdam Institut für Klimafolgenforschung

Abstract

Decarbonisation policies for the buildings sector set a strong emphasis on energy efficiency improvements with its corollaries: high energy standards for new buildings, subsidies for deep renovations and targets for high rates of renovation. Along this line of thoughts, supported by strands of literature on the benefits of efficiency, the EU has adopted the “Energy first principle” as a guiding criterion for its buildings policies. Nevertheless, this strategy has shown mixed results in the last years, or at least has not delivered the expected contribution to the decarbonisation of the sector. While the performance of European new buildings has improved significantly across the last decades, the downward trend of heat demand has stopped since the mid 2010’s and only 0.2% of the building stock is being renovated each year to the most ambitious standards. There are growing concerns regarding the capability of the sector to reach high energy efficiency levels in line with political objectives.

More fundamentally, the focus on energy demand reductions bears a strong issue when it comes to decarbonisation. While energy savings are important, reaching a carbon neutral building stock relies primarily on the reduction in the carbon content of energy through the recourse to carbon-free heat sources. The strong focus on energy efficiency hence unnecessarily narrows the scope of approaches available for the decarbonisation of buildings and potentially leads to higher decarbonisation costs.

In this paper, we want to shift the prioritisation of buildings decarbonisation from energy efficiency towards emission reductions via the penetration of carbon-free energy sources. We argue that first considering the needs and prerequisites for the penetration of low-carbon heat sources would be a more effective approach to reaching a carbon-neutral building stock. Starting from this premise, we reconsider the role of energy efficiency as an enabler for the diffusion of carbon-free energy and investigate the role(s) it could play to facilitate this diffusion.

We distinguish between two roles for energy efficiency. On the one hand, it influences the heating temperature requirements in buildings. In turn, low heating temperatures are a condition for a high penetration of clean heating technologies such as heat pumps or decarbonised district heating systems. On the other hand, the electrification of heating, implied by its decarbonisation, will set a great pressure on the power system because of the strong seasonality of the demand in the European context. The energy supply might not be able to cope with a strong peak demand in winter at reasonable costs, while at the same time facing its own decarbonisation challenge. Reductions of winter peak demand would alleviate the challenge to the power sector and therefore its decarbonisation costs.

We find that while some level of efficiency is necessary to reach low heating temperatures, there exist other measures, potentially cheaper, that could cool down the temperatures, and that high levels of efficiency are probably superfluous as far as lowering heating temperatures is concerned. Regarding the second role of efficiency, energy demand reductions clearly have a strong potential to alleviate the challenges posed by the electrification of heat to the power sector. In fact, the main rationale for energy demand reductions may actually be to reduce the peak demand. However, other options could secure power supply with renewable energy, though potentially at higher costs.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 2-205-22_Levesque_pres.pdf