Search eceee proceedings
Factor three emission reduction targets – telling the challenge for Energy Efficiency Programmes
Panel: 2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Thomas MM Guibentif, University of Geneva, Switzerland
Martin Patel, Université de Genève, Switzerland
Abstract
Emission reduction targets were put forward in the countdown to COP26 as policy makers tried to reaffirm their commitment to prevent climate and ecological collapse. Energy efficiency (EE) is seen as a key strategy to achieve these targets, thus EE programmes (EEP) face mounting expectations.
We conduct a participatory research on a regional EEP to understand how such programmes can address the challenge. In our case, the new political ambition translated into increases by a factor 3 to 100 (depending on the measures) in terms of number of EE measures to be implemented annually, with no additional human resources provided. The intuition was that, as the programme director put it, the EEP had to “rise from lead violinist to conductor” of the regional EE ecosystem.
Indeed, just as a “lead violinist” fuels the orchestra with its energy and experience, EEP typically facilitate the deployment of EE measures with subsidies and, sometimes, technical advice. In practice, EEPs are structured around one or several subsidy schemes and programme staff perform essentially operational tasks (processing applications, estimating and measuring savings, monitoring project implementation…) in order to run them. However, over the course of the workshops, it became clear that this approach will not be sufficient to reach the policy targets. On one hand, it is far from certain that enough potential beneficiaries will be involved with a sufficient degree of ambition in order to trigger the deployment of the required EE measures. On the other hand, the programme would not have the operational capacity to handle the volume of entering applications, should the deployments pick up pace as to reach the targets.
The proposed solution was to rise to a “conductor” role. Drawing on the “transition intermediary roles” introduced by [Kivimaa, 2014], we can understand this as leaving operational roles (e.g., technical support, administration, training…) to contractors or partners while endorsing more orchestral roles (networking, articulation of visions…). It then emerged from further discussions that the EEP had already been fulfilling part of these while developing and launching subsidy or support schemes. We conceptualized the typical path from the development of such schemes, in close contact with a few beneficiaries and installers, to their scaling up and uptake by other intermediaries (energy efficiency specialists, umbrella organizations…).
This scale-up seemed to hit two barriers when it came to the last stage (uptake by partners). First, the EEP’s credibility relies on an annual reporting of certified savings, the quality of which could not anymore be guaranteed if the EEP was no more directly tracing individual measures. Second, it turned out to be unclear what other functions the EEP could legitimately endorse, while the staff initially hired to run rather technical subsidy schemes did not have the know-how for networking and communication-related activities. As an example, the EEP does not have any profile on social media.
We suggest that these barriers arise from the fact that EE has become a goal rather than a means, fostering a strongly accountancy-driven approach based on energy or CO2 saving indicators. This also led to neglecting rebound as well as snowballing effects. Instead, the workshops provided the material for the creation of a programme design canvas linking the programme missions and corresponding tasks to encourage reflecting on and valuing the direct and indirect impacts of all the activities of the programme. This impact-aware approach to EEP design is meant to leverage EE as an entry point to achieve a deeper change towards the stated goal of a carbon-neutral society. Just as a conductor is not performing for his orchestra, so should EEPs be aware of their impact on the public.
Downloads
Download this display (photo) as pdf: 2-194-22-displayphoto.pdf
Panels of
1. Dynamics of consumption: less is more?
2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies
3. Policy, finance and governance
4. Monitoring and evaluation for a wise, just and inclusive transition
5. Towards sustainable and resilient communities
6. Energy-efficient and low-carbon mobility for all
7. Policies and programmes for better buildings
8. Innovations in products, systems and building technologies


