Search eceee proceedings
Multiple benefits of a financial incentive for retrofit in owner occupied houses
Panel: 2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Authors:
Marina Topouzi, CREDS, University of Oxford - Environmental Change Institute, United Kingdom
Tina Fawcett, Oxford University ECI, United Kingdom
Abstract
The challenge for retrofitting the owner-occupied sector is enormous. The slow progress not only highlights the need for a radical rethinking of the current financial retrofit schemes but also the need for a new regulatory framework that simplifies the whole retrofit process for the homeowners. The COVID-19 pandemic has fundamentally reshaped the ways in which people work and use their homes. The accelerated trend of home working continues to rise globally after the easing of restrictions in the ‘new normal’.
Previous work on retrofit incentives developed an innovative financial mechanism the ‘Retrofit Salary Sacrifice’ policy scheme to allow employers to provide loans to employees encouraging them to carry out retrofit energy improvements in their ‘home office’, repaid through the tax system via gross salary contributions. In this working from home was identified as a trigger for a specific subgroup of salaried homeowner employees to undertake retrofit works. The scheme builds on a simple connection between finance, and project management and appraisal to allow overcome a significant deployment barrier increasing confidence and trust to public revenue and private lenders.
In this paper the policy implications of the Retrofit Salary Sacrifice scheme were seen under the lens of multiple benefits framing to capture areas of impact and important points the financial incentive has over five sectors/stakeholders (i.e. Government and Local authorities; Companies and Institutions as employers; Private owned housing sector as employees; Private and public Financial institutions; Supply side companies and Retrofit energy professionals). The authors present an alternative visualisation of multiple benefits framing which draws the connections between stakeholders and the wider impact of Retrofit Salary Sacrifice scheme in energy efficiency retrofit policy. Insights from the analysis show positive economic impacts in all stakeholders that vary from stimulus for a retrofit service and job creation to operational energy use and CO2 emission savings for both companies and homeowners. Social impacts are mainly related to businesses (employers) and housing sector (employees) and concern health, employment and carbon inequality between them. It emphasises an opportunity where the energy efficiency of the domestic sectors can meet to balance the outsourced operations of the non-domestic sector. Environmental impacts are found at high level in governments and local authorities’ energy efficiency and Net Zero strategies as well as in individual companies’ environmental targets. Finally, political impacts in government bodies are related to the decision making of financial institutions and supply chain to create retrofit market capacity. Looking the multiple benefit framing of the scheme it helps understand the catalytic role it can have in the retrofit policy mix. It can also help towards more meaningful engagement with full diversity of stakeholders in retrofit sector and to develop better synergies between key roles and functions (e.g. employers, employees and investors, EPC/retrofit assessors, utilities and data companies, lenders, building control, professionals, installers, manufacturers). The analysis here can be used as a first step towards action for trialling the Retrofit Salary Sacrifice scheme. While it also responds to the call for more systematic empirical evidence in governmental policy making and evaluation of the multiple impacts of energy efficiency programmes.
The multiple benefit approach as developed in this paper also demonstrates a different way multiple benefits framework can be applied to support policy design and development of new policy ideas. The alternative visualisation highlights the importance of understanding the role and connections between stakeholders and the shared 'salient benefits' arguments that need to be made to boost retrofit uptake.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 2-322-22_TopuziFawcett_pres.pdf
Panels of
1. Dynamics of consumption: less is more?
2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies
3. Policy, finance and governance
4. Monitoring and evaluation for a wise, just and inclusive transition
5. Towards sustainable and resilient communities
6. Energy-efficient and low-carbon mobility for all
7. Policies and programmes for better buildings
8. Innovations in products, systems and building technologies


