Search eceee proceedings
How committed are utilities to help their clients saving energy without being obliged to do so? An analysis for Switzerland
Panel: 3. Policy, finance and governance
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Imane Fouiteh, University of Geneva, Switzerland
Martin Patel, University of Geneva, Switzerland
Daniel Cabrera, University of Geneva, Switzerland
Abstract
Among the many policy instruments introduced around the world to support energy efficiency (EE), we find in several countries Energy Efficiency Obligation schemes (EEO) imposed on energy utilities, which have the advantage of proximity and good information about the end-users’ energy needs. In countries where energy utilities are not subject to such legal obligations, there are only few studies on these market agents' relation with EE. We study the case of Switzerland, where the supply of electricity to end customers is ensured by roughly 600 utility companies of different sizes and legal forms. Large differences are found among these companies in their activities to promote EE among customers. This was examined by Blumer and Moser in 2013, along with the associated incentives and constraints. Since then, major changes have occurred in the context, mainly the Paris agreement, the Swiss Energy Strategy 2050, the power shortage risk, and the Swiss withdrawal from the negotiations with the EU which may affect the electricity agreements with neighboring countries.
We collected data of 59 utilities covering 31% of Swiss electricity consumption in the year 2020. Using an EE performance index (PEE) to determine the level of commitment of the utilities, we found that the overall average PEE slightly decreased since 2013, while observing a certain transition towards EE services that are more impactful and drive larger EE savings. In addition, utilities perceive more incentives to promote EE than before. Notably, the incentives of “Improving access to customers” and “Prospects of starting a new business line” have become more prominent, which can be explained by the approaching full liberalization that is pushing utilities towards improving their position in the competitive market. Also, due to the increased national and local ambitions, over half of utilities are now more sensitive to the political goals, especially public ones. At the same time, Swiss utilities perceive more constraints compared to 2013, mainly “lack of capital”, and that “EE programmes yield too little financial returns”. Even though a solution to such financial issues could be addressed by a national policy framework encouraging utilities saving energy, “the absence of an adequate policy framework” is interestingly not considered to be a significant constraint. In fact, this resistance towards policies to regulate EE is not only present on utilities’ side, but also among policy makers who rejected few motions on the subject. This brings us to the second part of the research, where we study an alternative, voluntary approach for utilities to implement EE Programmes (EEPs) . Building on the recommendations from literature on collaboration between utilities and with other key players for knowledge sharing and implementing common EEPs, we assessed the interest of Swiss utilities in collaborating. The utilities were found to be significantly more open to the idea of collaborating on voluntary basis, by a majority of 70%, than to to be subjected to new policies. The utilities interested in collaboration are mostly small and medium-sized, they reported lack of capital, staff, and time to promote EE and they seem to be primarily attracted by the informational and technical support (knowledge sharing, M&V methodologies). Future research may benefit from understanding the dynamics and roles of key players by analysing the long and successful experience with the “Energy Efficiency Collaboratives” in the U.S., and also by studying their stability in a potentially fully liberalized future market.
Downloads
Download this display as pdf: 3-085-22_Fouiteh_display.pdf
Panels of
1. Dynamics of consumption: less is more?
2. Efficiency and beyond: innovative energy demand policies
3. Policy, finance and governance
4. Monitoring and evaluation for a wise, just and inclusive transition
5. Towards sustainable and resilient communities
6. Energy-efficient and low-carbon mobility for all
7. Policies and programmes for better buildings
8. Innovations in products, systems and building technologies


