Search eceee proceedings

Ex-post evaluation of neighborhood projects within the German National Climate Initiative

Panel: 4. Monitoring and evaluation for a wise, just and inclusive transition

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Katja Schumacher, Öko-Institut, Institute for Applied Ecology, Germany
Victoria Liste, Öko-Institut
Dominik Jessing, ifeu
Lisa Muckenfuß, ifeu

Abstract

The German National Climate Initiative (NCI) is part of Germany’s climate strategy. It aims at stimulating behavioral change and investment in different target groups and areas that have not yet been tapped by other instruments. It covers a wide range of projects ranging from direct investment support for technologies to informational and educational programs.

This paper presents the evaluation of the support program “shortcuts to combatting climate change” which is funded by the NCI and addresses initiatives to conduct climate change projects at the neighborhood level. It funds collaborative activities for everyday actions of citizens by bringing together different actors, initiating local initiatives, reducing barriers and setting examples for multiplication and imitation.

Between 2016 and 2019, more than 100 projects in Germany were funded with just over €9 million. The evaluation reveals a high transformation potential for these projects resulting from the involvement of local actors and target groups and the direct reference to everyday activities. Many activities are able to continue beyond the funding period on the basis of the acquired skills and structures. One obstacle to successful implementation is the high administrative burden, especially for grant recipients with no previous experience in applying for funding.

The importance and success of the program is widely accepted and qualitatively shown by the evaluation. Yet, the evaluation of the quantitative impact on GHG emissions reduction faced severe challenges. Reasons include lack of data, complex impact chains and lack of monitoring capabilities and capacities by the mostly volunteer-based project implementers. GHG reduction effects were thus only calculated for a limited number of projects, specifically for cargo bike initiatives and food sharing projects. The question remains how to scientifically assess and communicate the contribution of these project to climate change mitigation.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 4-052-22_Schumacher_pres.pdf