Search eceee proceedings

Home-meanings framework to analyse and promote the diverse benefits of low-carbon dwellings

Panel: 7. Policies and programmes for better buildings

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Yekatherina Bobrova, University of Oxford, United Kingdom
George Papachristos, Dept. of Industrial Engineering & Innovation Sciences, The Netherlands

Abstract

One important strategy to reduce operational energy use in dwellings and mitigate climate change is to motivate homeowners to retrofit. Building research and policy typically consider the rational reasoning behind such motivations in terms of health and well-being considerations, climate concerns and altruistic behaviours, and financial considerations, i.e. returns on investment and savings on energy bills. However, this focus on rational reasoning neglects emotional aspects of how homeowners themselves make sense of the potential benefits of low-carbon dwellings.

To complement this focus, the thematic analysis in this paper collates insights from: (i) 8 interviews with homeowners from the SuperHomes network, who achieved significant carbon emission reductions through retrofit activities; (ii) 10 interviews with homeowners, who did retrofit of different depth and have expertise in energy retrofit or access to such expertise; (iii) a workshop with 36 participants, representing various actors interested to advance domestic energy retrofit activities in the UK, such as actors from industry, government, academia, non-for-profit organisations and other intermediary actors.

The lens used in the analysis integrates: (i) the homeowner individual frames on the meaning of low-carbon dwellings, that underpin their motives; (ii) the home-meanings framework, developed around the concepts of affordance, practice and perezhivanie (emotional and cognitive experience) to explain homeowner individual frames.

Three themes are found to capture the emotional aspects of how homeowners make sense of the potential benefits of low-carbon dwellings: (i) Happy – a low-carbon dwelling is a better platform to be in control of one’s environment, and subsequently, be happy in one’s home. The concept is linked to the feelings of comfort, ease, relaxation and love, which are closely associated with the perception of an ideal home. (ii) Caring – a low-carbon dwelling is an expression of one’s environmental identity and involves caring for the immediate community, future generations and the whole Earth. The concept is linked to the notions of self and identity, community cohesion and the feeling of belonging. (iii) Future-resilient – a low-carbon dwelling is a place with greater resilience, including more durable building components, financial resilience to volatile energy prices, resilience to the changing political environment that is transitioning towards tightening requirements for energy use and carbon emissions, and resilience to climate change. The concept is linked to the feelings of safety, security and control.

This research proposes integration of the benefits of low-carbon dwellings in a single frame, and their promotion as a single package – Home for the Common Future (HCF). The abbreviation can simultaneously be used to describe motivations involving rational reasoning – Health and well-being, Climate and Financial concerns; as well as motivations involving emotional reactions – Happy, Caring, Future-resilient.

The proposed individual frame – Home for the Common Future – together with the home-meanings framework can be used to develop a range of motivational narratives that are emotionally compelling to the homeowners. For instance, for a family with young children a message about one's happiness and wellbeing could include a picture of children playing in front of a big triple-glazed window (practice), and enjoying themselves (perezhivanie), while there is heavy rain and wind outside. Yet, the weather does not distract the children from their game, as there is no sense of cold air flow in the proximity of the window (affordance).

Funding: This research was partially supported by the Economic and Social Research Council (UK) under the project Fast-tracking Low-Energy Use via Retrofit (FLEUR) [grant number: ES/V012606/1]; and by UK Research and Innovation the Centre for Research into Energy Demand Solutions [grant number: EP/R035288/1].

Downloads

Download this display as pdf: 7-010-22_Bobrova_Papachristos_display.pdf