Search eceee proceedings

Co-Creating Transformative Policy Mixes for Energy-Intensive Industries in Germany and the UK

Panel: 9. Deep decarbonisation of industry

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Jakob Wachsmuth, Fraunhofer ISI, Germany
Philine Warnke, Fraunhofer ISI
Sarah Seus, Fraunhofer ISI
Thomas Jackwerth-Rice, Fraunhofer ISI

Abstract

In view of the long-term climate targets of Germany and the UK, their industry sectors need to be geared to a pathway towards climate neutrality rapidly, which requires radi-cal process innovations in energy-intensive industries such as the production of steel, cement and basic chemicals. There are various techno-economic scenarios how to achieve this, but there is also a long-standing debate on the usefulness of model-based transformation pathways for informing policy makers. The main reasons are that the models usually do not address certain socio-technical aspects (Wesseling et al. 2017) and that the tacit knowledge of stakeholders is not taken into account. One proposed solution is the co-creation of transformative policy mixes with stakeholders, extending the model-based pathways to socio-technical scenarios with qualitative assessments of the transformation pathways (Rogge, Pfluger, and Geels 2020). In particular, the identi-fication of central bottlenecks can raise awareness of the challenges to be tackled by policies and be integrated in future modeling exercises (Geels, McMeekin, and Pfluger 2020).

In our contribution, we describe the conceptual background for co-creating transforma-tive policy mixes with key stakeholders (cf. Wachsmuth et al. 2021b) and provide first steps towards an application to the energy-intensive industries in Germany and the UK. Koasidis et al. (2020) have considered the decarbonisation of these industries from a sectoral innovation and system failures perspective. According to Koasidis et al. (2020), the carbon intensity of production has been relatively constant in these sectors. So the transformation to a GHG-neutral economy as targeted by both countries is still in an early stage for the energy-intensive industries, although various industry associations have recently embraced the vision of a transformation to GHG neutrality.

Elaborating on Koasidis et al. (2020) and an analysis of EU industry policy by Wachsmuth et al. (2021a), we come up with an indicative list of key bottlenecks and a first elaboratation of elements of a suitable transformative policy mix for the energy-intensive industries in Germany and the UK. Furthermore, we outline how to map the relevant stakeholder groups and provide an outlook on the further elaboration of the transformative policy mix in stakeholder workshops to take place in summer 2022.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 9-176-22_Wachsmuth_pres.pdf