Search eceee proceedings

Steel decarbonisation in China – a top-down optimization model for exploring the first steps

Panel: 9. Deep decarbonisation of industry

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Zhenxi Li, Lund university, Sweden
Lars Nilsson, Lund University, Sweden
Max Åhman, Lund University, Sweden
Fredrik Andersson, Lund University, Sweden

Abstract

China produced 1065Mt of crude steel in 2020, accounting for 56.7% of global production. This production caused about 15% of total Chinese GHG emissions. In September 2020, China announced its national climate target to “peak emissions before 2030 and achieve carbon neutrality before 2060.” For the steel industry, China in 2021 signaled the ambition to peak emissions already in 2025 and reduce them by 30% by 2030. These targets were never officially adopted and in 2022 the target of peaking steelmaking emissions by 2030 was adopted by the Chinese government. Despite this, some steel companies have maintained their earlier targets to peak even before 2025 (e.g., HBIS and Baowu). In addition to climate targets, China has adopted several targets to reduce air pollution from steelmaking (e.g., for particulate matter, sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides). Although there are often synergies between reducing carbon emissions and other pollution it may have implications for the geographical location and timing of measures if one is prioritized over the other.

Strategies for reducing carbon emissions and pollution must also be understood in the context of overcapacity which is currently estimated at 130-350 Mt in China and the steel demand in China is expected to decrease in the coming decades. In the short term, a key measure to reduce both carbon emissions and pollution is by switching to scrap-based secondary steelmaking through electric arc furnaces (EAFs). The share of secondary steelmaking in China is currently much lower than in other countries but it is likely to increase as the economy matures.

Tackling these challenges not only need national target set by the central government, but also need provincial governments to coordinate. Local governments have rights to design local policies, allocated targets could make national goal achievement more effective.

Recent studies have explored long-term breakthrough technology options for China as well as short term strategies (where scrap-based EAF steelmaking is the main option) but so far only at the national level and without attention to the recently announced climate ambitions. Furthermore, most studies are focused on either carbon dioxide emissions or other pollutants. Over time, the policy focus on local air pollution problems has been extended to also include greenhouse gas emissions.

In this study we built a top-down optimization model to assess the potential future regional allocation of production capacities and secondary steelmaking for meeting the previous climate ambitions for 2025-2030, and at the same time reduce capacity. For the purpose of understanding the pollution implications of a cost optimal strategy for reducing carbon emissions we compare it against a strategy for minimizing pollution .

Our analysis shows that peak carbon by 2025 and 30% emission reductions by 2030 is possible but scrap availability will be a challenge. The overall cost for our two scenarios is roughly the same but lead to different patterns of demand for scrap over time. If reducing pollution impact was the main objective, it would lead to 26-32% less pollution impact than when optimizing on abatement costs and a different geographical distribution of production capacity.

The results show that China may have been overly cautious when setting the target to peak steel industry emissions in 2030. The limited scrap availability highlights need for China to increase quality scrap collection or scrap imports. Furthermore, policy should consider the balance between accelerating the introduction of scrap based EAF steelmaking versus reducing overall capacity. Also, the results indicate that policy should pay attention to the trade-off between cost optimal mitigation and pollution impact. Policy must also consider strategies for the long term and how a shift to secondary steelmaking can be followed by a shift in primary processing technologies to reach the 2060 goal of carbon neutrality.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 9-261-22_Zhenxi_pres.pdf