Search eceee proceedings

A distributional analysis of European countries' contribution to sufficiency in achieving a low energy future

Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Elliott Johnson, University of Leeds, United Kingdom
Sam Betts-Davies, University of Leeds

Abstract

A recent proliferation in low energy demand (LED) scenarios has seen a consensus begin to emerge around the potential for energy demand reduction (EDR) across developed economies, with absolute reductions of 50-55% by 2050, compared with 2020, being estimated as achievable. Realising these LED futures is not possible with efficiency improvements alone, and draw on more radical methods for reducing our demand, such as sufficiency, which ensures that people’s basic energy needs are met equitably, whilst unnecessary overconsumption is avoided. Previous work that assessed the compatibility of a UK LED scenario found that a low energy pathway (i.e. overall reductions of 52%) was not compatible with minimum energy requirements at current or increased levels of inequality. However, this could be avoided by either by reducing income inequality, or by ensuring that the most efficient technologies were available at all income levels. However, the previous work looked only at absolute energy, whereas this analysis looks at energy services, which are more directly associated with wellbeing.

The recently published CLEVER scenario, which is premised upon a sufficiency framework, is a Europe-wide assessment of the potential for sufficiency with individual but related country pathways that are aggregated up to the European level. These individual pathways allow us to explore each country’s relative contribution to sufficiency-led EDR out to 2050. This analysis, framed by the concept of 'Decent Living Energy', explores how inequality of energy service demands (ESDs) changes over time across countries, and how much energy-income inequality reduction is required for Europe to cut its energy demand in half. 'Decent Living Energy' estimates conceptualise the minimum energy required to meet the basic human needs, prerequisite to achieving wellbeing. They are a useful benchmark for assessing projected energy service demands' compatibility with social needs.

Gini coefficients are calculated across a multitude of energy service indicators (e.g. residential floor space, passenger-kilometres), as well as overall final energy demand, for current and 2050 levels. The purpose of which is to demonstrate the degree to which countries that currently have high levels of energy services need to reduce their demand to ensure that everyone can achieve the required level of well-being whilst remaining within planetary limits. Similarly, income distributions are combined with ESD-income elasticities to produce a distributional analysis of the spread of ESDs across income deciles to determine if those at the lower end of the income ranges are meeting their minimum energy service needs. Income Gini coefficients are varied to assess where acceptable ranges of income inequality lie, whereby those who use the least amount of energy services are able to sufficiently meet their needs.

Whilst modelling exercises have demonstrated that energy demand reduction is imperative to achieve the net zero transition, a greater understanding is needed to ensure that LED futures are just and inclusive. Understanding differentiated national responsibilities to EDR within Europe, as well as where access to pre-requisite levels of energy service demands to achieve decent living standards must be increased, will aid policymakers in developing targeted mechanisms, ensuring that low-income countries are not left behind.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-203-24_Johnson_pres.pdf