Search eceee proceedings

Can sufficiency be achieved through ‘re-programming’ existing resource-intensive infrastructures and institutions?

Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Toke Haunstrup Christensen, BUILD Aalborg University, Denmark
Kirsten Gram-Hanssen, Aalborg University, Denmark

Abstract

There is an urgent need in affluent countries to adopt everyday practices that entail significant reductions in resource consumption. Today’s resource-intensive practices are contingent on and unfold within existing material infrastructures and social institutions that have been established in times of abundance of cheap fossil fuels. While acknowledging that thorough changes in consumption require thorough changes in infrastructures and organizations, it is also evident that such radical changes will not happen as fast as the climate and biodiversity crises demand. In addition, deep changes in infrastructures would in itself entail massive resource investments, e.g. in the demand for rare earths or fossil fuels, and thereby exacerbate today’s overshoot of the planetary boundaries. Therefore, the adoption of less resource-intensive everyday practices must largely take place within existing infrastructures and institutions.

This abstract explores theoretically and empirically the possible pathways for adopting new, sufficiency-based everyday practices within existing resource-intensive infrastructures and institutions (e.g. existing material arrangements). It does so by developing the concept of “re-programming”, which defines two different, but closely interconnected, approaches to the shift towards sufficiency: Promoting sufficiency through either performing everyday practices in different ways within existing materialities and social institutions or by “modifying” or “adjusting” existing material arrangements and institutions in ways that promote resource-light practices. Main focus will be on the latter.

First, the abstract presents a review of how the sufficiency literature conceptualizes the relationship between resource-light everyday practices and material arrangements and institutions. This leads to the proposal of “reprogramming” as a concept of and strategy for transitions towards sufficiency. Second, the abstract builds on empirical findings from a recent interview study of young people moving from city centers to suburban areas. The empirical analysis focuses selectively on examples of the young people attempting to keep up previous resource-efficient practices (e.g. cycling or saving heated floor space) within a suburban context built for a resource-intensive living (e.g. automobility and detached homes). Our main focus will be on mobility practices, as these turned out to be the domain of practices that attracted most attention in the participants’ own narratives about how moving out of the city centre had changed their everyday lives.

Finally, the paper concludes with a discussion of possible strategies, based on the concept of reprogramming, to promote sufficiency-based practices within existing resource-intensive materialities and institutions. Here, we will draw on and relate to practice-theoretical concepts, such as material arrangements (T. Schatzki), practice architectures (S. Kemmis) and institutional rhythms (S. Blue), as well as provide specific examples of how existing institutional and material arrangements might be reprogrammed (e.g., changing car-based infrastructures through turning highways into Bus Rapid Transits or developing combined mobility and activity hubs in suburban centres).

Reprogramming represents both a way of thinking, e.g. in policymaking, and a way of designing, e.g. in urban planning, and the paper suggests that strategies of reprogramming can be a relatively simple and quick way of promoting thorough changes in everyday practices towards sufficiency.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-217-24_Christensen_Pres.pdf