Search eceee proceedings
Exploring the scope of action for sufficiency oriented energy policies in Norway
Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Author:
Gisle Solbu, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Norway
Tomas Moe Skjølsvold, Norwegian Unviersity of Science and Technology
Marius Korsnes, Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Abstract
From being a niche concept, sufficiency-oriented thinking is now gaining traction in mainstream policy-making, emphasizing the importance of meeting people’s basic needs equitably and respecting ecological limits while avoiding excessive energy demands. As an example, the IPCC has recently highlighted the significant role sufficiency policies can play in mitigating emissions by complementing efficiency and renewable energy policies. Moreover, the recent European energy crises has underscored the benefits of sufficiency as a strategy to alleviate pressure on the energy system. However, while sufficiency is becoming a more widespread concept to address urgent issues, we see fewer attempts to engage in a deeper discussion about its implications on the core direction of our energy systems and the types of activities that we either want to encourage or constrain. We thus lack a contextual understanding of the scope of action for sufficiency-oriented energy policies, which gives room for questioning the feasibility of such pathways.
Our paper will gain insights into this challenge by studying political parties and the public’s perception of energy-sufficiency strategies in Norway, using qualitative interviews and quantitative survey data triangulation. First, we investigate how political parties across the left-wing/right-wing axis perceive their agency, political willingness and political feasibility to push for more transformative interventions into the efficiency and growth-oriented practices that underpin most of today's policies. We find that all political parties, from left to right, acknowledge the need for sufficiency-oriented policy measures that address energy demand reductions, both through reduction in direct energy use and indirectly through reduced consumption of goods. However, we also identify a series of “ideological lock-ins” that limit how politicians experience their own scope of action to push for more radical policy interventions. E.g., from the perspective of a leftist socialist ideology, overconsumption is perceived as a systemic issue derived from capitalist structures, causing reluctance to push for policies that unfairly target individuals. From the liberal right, sufficiency practices should emerge naturally through market mechanisms, and there is reluctance towards state interventions that enforce changes. From both wings there exist imaginations of voters being unwilling to accept disruptive changes to everyday life and societal trajectories. As a result, the viable political options for engaging with sufficiency are limited to tweaking existing instruments and moderate interventions, like removing VAT on repair work or banning planned obsolescence. In sum, the politicians frame sufficiency as an add-on to existing efficiency and growth-oriented instruments.
Next, in our analysis, we aim to compare the political parties' perceptions with an analysis of the general public’s willingness to reduce energy consumption levels and their perception of sufficiency-oriented policies. This comparison will draw on a representative survey of the Norwegian population on the willingness to take part in transformative and potentially disruptive changes that can contribute to reducing energy-demanding practices. The comparative analysis will serve as a basis for developing a bottom-up understanding of short-term and long-term opportunities and challenges for sufficiency measures that are sensitive to the political context in which they will be implemented.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 1-053-24_Solbu_pres.pdf














