Search eceee proceedings

Integrating ‘bottom-up’ and ‘top-down’ approaches in climate policy

Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Tina Nyfors, Finland

Abstract

Several governments have presented climate target like net zero by 2050, but the means on how to reach them are largely missing. This abstract concerns integrating ‘bottom-up’ and ‘top-down’ approaches of sufficiency and efficiency. The bottom-up approach concentrates on a Finnish grassroot degrowth network, whereas the ‘top-down’ approach focuses on sufficiency-oriented climate policy. The aim is to examine how these could be combined to support a strong sustainability transformation.

The policy approach applies a sufficiency perspective based on Spengler (2018). Focus is on the steps following the strategy of ramping up eco-efficiency - recomposing consumption - including reducing consumption (Gough 2017). Policies entail systematically steering consumption away from identified carbon hotspots towards low-carbon options.

The grassroots approach builds on an ongoing empirical study on understandings of sufficiency in a Finnish grassroots network. Preliminary results indicate that multiple dimensions, including sufficiency as a criticism and sufficiency as a solution, concerning, for example, the growth based economic system, overconsumption, equality, human-nature relations, way of organizing human relations, and the nature of work.

The root causes of the sustainability challenges are deeply intertwined with how the state works. Economic growth as a fundamental interest contradicts the goal of ecological sustainability, given the impossibility of indefinite growth. While ecological sustainability becoming the primary imperative of the state seems unlikely, it holds unique capacities for regulation, controlling material flows and providing social welfare. This points to the need of integrating “bottom-up” and “top-down” approaches.

While building on understandings of sufficiency in Finland, the implications for policy as a leverage for sustainability transformations may be of relevance for affluent, overconsuming economies more broadly.

Errata

The correct version of the presentation has been uploaded. (2024-08-27)

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-204-24_Nyfors_pres.pdf