Search eceee proceedings

The acceptance of more sufficient, 1.5-degree lifestyles by citizens: individual and structural barriers and enablers

Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Kristóf Vadovics, GreenDependent Institute, Hungary
Edina Vadovics, GreenDependent Institute, Hungary

Abstract

The Paris Agreement defines the goal of not exceeding 1.5°C global warming compared to pre-industrial levels. To make this objective more relevant to everyday lifestyles, it was expressed as per capita carbon footprints to be reached by 2030 (2.5 t CO2e/cap/yr) and 2050 (0.7 t CO2e/cap/yr) respectively, and the term “1.5-degree lifestyles” was conceptualised. Our project, EU 1.5° Lifestyles, identifies and explores behaviour-, and technology and financial investment based lifestyle options that citizens ought to implement in the most impactful consumption domains of housing, mobility, nutrition and leisure to reduce their carbon footprint and reach 1.5-degree lifestyles. In this presentation we focus on housing and mobility, primarily in Hungary, but comparing the results to the four other ‘case countries’ we studied at a general level (Germany, Latvia, Spain and Sweden).

In the project, we developed a mixed methods study comprised of several steps: first we identified impactful lifestyle options, and the enabling/obstructing structures relating to them. For both, we conducted literature review and expert interviews, and relied on the expertise of the consortium. We followed by organising Thinking Labs for both citizens and stakeholders. Importantly, this methodology is part of a larger research process that includes further citizen and stakeholder Thinking Labs to learn about rebound and spill-over effects as well as contribute to visioning and creating solutions.

As for our results, we first present the housing and mobility options in order of their preference by citizens, both for Hungary and the average of the case countries. There are both differences and similarities between the domains and groups. Eg., in the order of preference for the options, there are differences between Hungary and the five-country average in the housing domain, but not in mobility. Then, for both groups, in the housing domain citizens prefer options that are below-average-impact and require financial investment rather than behaviour change. In the mobility domain, their preference indicates readiness to adopt above-average-impact and behaviour-change-based options, eg., giving up driving for cycling or public transport. In both domains and groups, options related to sharing (household devices, living space or cars) and downsizing are among the least preferred.

Looking at enablers for sufficient, 1.5-degree lifestyles, at the individual level participants reported saving costs and being true to ones’ values as important motivations. At the structural level, ease of implementation, and taxes and bans were mentioned. As for barriers, the boundary between the individual and the structural levels was less clear. Lack of financial resources, bad experience with an option (either personal or societal, e.g., enforced sharing in ‘communist’ countries) were reported along with existing social norms and traditions, lack of infrastructure or services, and inappropriate product design. However, importantly, when asked, both citizens and stakeholders were able to create contexts and conditions that could facilitate adopting even the least preferred options.

To conclude, we present implications for policies supporting sufficient, 1.5-degree lifestyles, eg., relating to the meaningful involvement of citizens to co-develop solutions, the need for multi-stakeholder dialogue to enchance understanding between different fields of policy (and research), and the need to make policies country-specific with attention to the socio-political and cultural context.

Acknowledgements

We would like to thank the EU 1.5° Lifestyles Consortium for contributing to the development of the research methodology, collecting data and participating in the analysis.

The research presented here received funding from the European Union’s H2020 Research and Innovation programme under grant agreement no. 101003880. The sole responsibility for the content of this abstract lies with the authors.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 1-286-24_Vadovics_Pres.pdf