Search eceee proceedings
The socio-economic factors of sufficiency lifestyles: Empirical evidence for the elaboration of socially just decarbonisation policies
Panel: 1. Dynamics of consumption
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Aurore Flipo, négaWatt, France
Abigail Alexander-Haw, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research ISI, Germany
Fiona Breucker, Jacques Delors Institute, France
Elisabeth Dütschke, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research ISI, Germany
Abstract
Sufficiency consists of less materially intensive consumption patterns, focusing on well-being rather than material wealth. Such sustainable consumption patterns are commonly referred to as lifestyles and are increasingly seen as a key driver for achieving decarbonisation.
However, lifestyles have long been described as a crucial element of social stratification and social distinction processes within society (Bourdieu, 2015). Sustainable consumption in general is typically associated in the literature with high social status (Carfagna et al., 2014; Kennedy and Givens, 2019). Nevertheless, higher income households tend to emit more carbon (Jorgenson et al., 2018), while low income households tend to have lower carbon footprints (Duarte et al., 2021; Sampedro et al., 2022). Sufficiency should be distinguished from sustainable consumption, since sufficiency designates absolute reduction of consumption levels (Kropfeld, 2023) and thus, lower demand for goods and services (Samadi et al., 2017). While sustainable consumption and its determinants are well-documented, further research is warranted on the concept of sufficiency, the social stratification aspects of sufficiency orientations, and sufficiency lifestyles.
This contribution is based on the interdisciplinary H2020 project FULFILL (Fundamental Decarbonisation through Sufficiency by Lifestyle Changes). It aims to investigate the socio-demographic characteristics associated with sufficiency lifestyles. Furthermore, it investigates the drivers and barriers of sufficiency, and discusses policy avenues that can relieve these barriers and encourage sufficiency.
We use a mixed methods design. We use data from demographically representative surveys in Italy, Germany, Latvia, and Denmark (N=5080) based on both carbon footprints and well-being indicators. We categorise respondents into five sufficiency lifestyle groups based on their carbon footprint and the well-being measure. We operationalise a sufficiency as a lifestyle with low-carbon footprint and a high score on the well-being index. A low carbon footprint was defined in relative terms, i.e., as a footprint in the lowest quarter within the respective country. Similarly, we distinguished respondents in the lowest carbon footprint quantile into above and below median well-being. Based on these steps, we create five lifestyle groups. To establish connections between lifestyle group membership and various socio-economic and additional variables, we employ neural networks to estimate multinomial log-linear models using the R package nnet (Venables and Ripley, 2002).
We then analyse the motivations and practices of participants in sufficiency-oriented intentional communities in the five countries, based on in-depth socio-anthropological interviews (N=90). We analyse in particular the motivations, biographical trajectories and involvement processes of these individuals into sufficiency initiatives and practices.In a third section, we derive policy recommendations from these empirical findings.
We find that in our sample sufficiency lifestyles are positively associated with corresponding attitudes such as sufficiency orientation or a heightened environmental identity, and negatively associated with aspects of material deprivation.
Based on qualitative research, we also find that individuals engaged in sufficiency-oriented practices tend to benefit from economic, social, and cultural resources that allow them to overcome energy dependency and dedicate time to this endeavour. Gender is another important factor, appearing both in quantitative and qualitative data and suggesting that women are more engaged in sufficiency-oriented practices and lifestyles, than men.
Finally, based on this empirical evidence we explore potential avenues for democratisation of sufficiency-oriented lifestyles, including establishing binding rules through a democratic process that curb overconsumption while offering appealing low-carbon lifestyles for all.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 1-043-24_Flipo_Pres.pdf














