Search eceee proceedings
Compensating domestic customers for electricity grid services: the challenge of allocating the costs and benefits of controlled domestic water heating
Panel: 2. Future and innovative policies
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Authors:
Chris Granda, Energy Solutions, USA
Helen Davis, Energy Solutions, USA
Daniela Urigwe, Energy Solutions, USA
George Chapman, Energy Solutions, USA
Abstract
Domestic electric storage water heaters (ESWH) are designed to consume electricity, store energy as hot water, and then supply hot water to users upon demand. This ability creates a significant demand response resource potential. The US and the EU each currently have close to 57 million ESWH, almost all of which operate autonomously and do not communicate with the electricity distribution grid. Today, when ESWH consume electricity is determined by when ESWH users consume hot water. Because domestic utility customers tend to share hot water usage patterns, ESWH are often drivers of domestic sector peak electricity demand.
Trends in technology and regulation in both the US and EU may create opportunities to better integrate ESWH into grids and develop the demand response potential for this important household appliance. Three US states already require that most ESWHs be sold with some degree of demand response enabling technology and more US states are considering similar regulations. A pending update to US federal minimum energy performance standards (MEPS) is expected to shift the US ESWH market from electric resistance to heat pump technology with implications for ESWH demand response. The size of the ESWH fleets in the US and the EU may also increase in coming years as the result of electrification policies and market forces.
Jurisdictions in both the US and EU are experimenting with innovative electricity tariffs to incentivize customers to adopt demand response capable ESWH. Today the infrastructure needed to turn fleets of ESWH into demand response resources is still in its infancy. The incremental costs associated with demand-response-capable or “smart” ESWH are significant and are now largely borne by consumers. However, the consumer benefits from participating in nascent ESWH demand response schemes is not well defined. To reach a future with fully realized ESWH demand response capability is now less a challenge of technology development and more a challenge of distributing costs and benefits appropriately.
This paper provides a practical perspective on domestic sector demand resource programme design for ESWH from the perspective of energy efficiency programme designers and explores the ESWH potential demand response resource with a focus on the ways that domestic electricity customers may be compensated for providing demand response services with their ESWH. The authors review and contrast approaches to recruiting and compensating domestic smart ESWH owners as participants in demand response schemes. The authors draw primarily from experience in the US but also reference research from Europe and other regions.
Downloads
Download this paper as pdf: 2-095-24_Granda.pdf
Download this presentation as pdf: 2-095-24_Granda_pres.pdf














