Search eceee proceedings

Green Heat For All 2: the gap-o-meter of the heating & cooling decarbonisation

Panel: 2. Future and innovative policies

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Davide Sabbadin, EEB European Environmental Bureau, Belgium
Gunnar Boye Olesen, INFORSE
Jose Campos Filho, INFORSE
Ann Vikkelsø, INFORSE
Béla Munkácsy, INFORSE
Tibor Marik, INFORSE
Bich DAO, European Environmental Bureau, Belgium

Abstract

Shifting as little as half of the annual €3.2 billion fossil heating subsidies paid by Member States to go to extra support for heat pumps and solar instead can transition Europe to 100% renewable heat before 2040 in a fair way, making significant headway for EU climate neutrality.

The study takes a mid-to low-income household as a reference in all analysed EU countries to investigate the extra investment needed for a transition that will leave no one behind.

The model is a simplified one that looks at the current replacement cost of a fossil fuel boiler with another boiler or renewable heating technologies.

To stay realistic, the tech we chose for each Member State matches their heating demand, with air-to-water heat pumps for colder climates, but air-to-air combined with solar thermal energy for hot water in warmer ones.

The model also integrates the existing subsidies and standard consumption patterns per country, and calculates the existing gap in subsidies to achieve the feasibility of the full decarbonisation of heating at household, country and EU-level.

The findings reveal that manageable extra investment totaling €21 billion over the upcoming decade and a half will ensure a fairer and cleaner energy landscape across the whole bloc. What this entails is a 7-year payback for all citizens installing heat pumps and full upfront cost coverage for families in need. If coupled with carbon taxation, the investment is even more affordable, at €14 billion. The study also encompasses an analysis of the existing subsidies schemes for heating and cooling technologies in the different EU countries.

Other significant findings include:

1) When it comes to day-to-day use, running a heat pump is already cheaper than running a gas or oil boiler in all Member States, except for Belgium where solar power is needed to breakeven.

2) With current subsidies, 16 Member States already have access to affordable heat pumps that payback within 7 years from the first investment, including Germany, Italy, Spain, Poland and the Nordics. With carbon taxes, this number becomes 20 out of 27.

3) Belgium, Ireland and the Netherlands are the least ambitious in setting targets for renewable energy share in heating and cooling, all aiming for below 10%.

4) Italy and Poland still generously subsidise fossil heating and installation of new boilers. Belgium continues to marginally support coal heating technology in some forms.

At the time of the research (October 2023), 10 European countries still finance fossil boilers (it is now 9 countries) while many mid-to-low-income families struggle to afford the switch to cleaner and cheaper heating due to the high upfront investments associated with heat pumps. However, the finding of this study puts into perspective the scale of this public investment compared to the amount that has already been poured and continues to pour down the fossil heating drain.

While a rough model, the findings are a narrative tool showcasing the feasibility of this transition, specifically with climate justice in mind. This is combatting the growing populistic attacks on EU and national buildings energy efficiency policies, often painted as an idealistic Brussels agenda. The findings of this study imply otherwise, that it is possible to make this transition fair and centred on mid-to-low income households: the funds are there to be shifted, it is simply a matter of political will to prioritise cheap and clean heat for the people over the fossil fuel industry.

In fact, the study shows that by redirecting current fossil heating spending into extra support for renewable heating immediately, we could theoretically decarbonise the whole heating stock by 2030, covering 100% of the upfront cost for the 30% of boiler users who are low-income or impoverished.

The study is available at https://www.coolproducts.eu/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/Green-Heat-for-All-2-Final.pdf

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 2-166-24_Sabbadin_Pres.pdf