Search eceee proceedings

Grid impacts of Seattle’s Building Emissions Performance Standard: a generalized modeling study & load impact analysis

Panel: 2. Future and innovative policies

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Madeline Kostic, Seattle City Light, USA
Mazen Daher, Electric Power Research Institute
Siva Sankaranarayanan, Electric Power Research Institute
Maggie Sheng, Electric Power Research Institute

Abstract

The City of Seattle’s ambitious Buildings Emissions Performance Standard (BEPS) requires all buildings over 20,000 square feet (1,860 square meters) to reduce greenhouse gas emissions over time, eventually to zero by 2050. BEPS is expected to lower Seattle’s total greenhouse gas emissions from buildings by 27% by 2050. The most technologically feasible and cost-effective route to achieve these emissions reductions is for building owners to electrify fossil fuel end-uses, given Seattle City Light’s status as a carbon-neutral utility. The electrification of space conditioning, water heating, and cooking will cause increases in electricity consumption and, in many cases, result in increases in electric service sizes. For the customer, electric service upgrades translate into higher electrification project costs and typically longer construction timelines. For the utility, individual and cumulative customer service upgrades will increase workloads for customer service and engineering staff and require distribution system upgrades.

BEPS combined with Seattle’s energy benchmarking data of over 3,000 buildings enable the utility to precisely project where and when building electrification will occur. This study applies the modeled outcomes of several efficiency and decarbonization measures to building benchmarking data. A multi-step approach is undertaken, wherein (1) the sample stock is characterized based on typology, vintage, and heating fuel; (2) end-use makeup is estimated based on EnergyPlus prototypes developed as part of a prior study conducted by EPRI; (3) the obtained end-use makeups are scaled based on benchmarking data, to obtain a unique composite for every building in the set; (4) efficient electrification measures are applied to the composite benchmarks based on outcomes identified in EnergyPlus, from which (5) impacts to electric infrastructure, costs, and emissions are assessed.

This study is vital for understanding the role of electrification in meeting BEPS at different stages along the compliance horizon, the geographic load impacts to inform short- and long-term planning at the electric utility, and the potential customer costs associated with compliance. This generalized modeling methodology is widely applicable to other jurisdictions that have building performance standards, climate action plans, and/or energy benchmarking data.

The results of the study demonstrate that BEPS will have diverse impacts for both customers and the grid. Building types with relatively large baseline electrical loads, such as office buildings and grocery stores, which have high ventilation (the former) and refrigeration (the latter), are much less susceptible to high peak load exacerbation than building types with minimal baseline electrical loads, such as multifamily housing. The average per building increase in peak load (measured by kilowatts) is 35% with a range of 2% to 72%. Likewise, load growth is not spread evenly across the utility’s service area and is concentrated in the Downtown and University District neighborhoods. Over the course of the Seattle BEPS’s compliance horizon, compliance will result in an increase of individual covered buildings’ peak loads amounting to a combined 154 megawatts. The utility can expect an increased volume of increasingly complex customer service upgrades due to (a) significant increases in individual buildings’ peak loads, and (b) increases in the number of buildings with a peak load exceeding 500 kilowatts (an important complexity threshold for service upgrades). Furthermore, widespread customer electrification will lead to grid-side distribution upgrades to meet increased electrical loads, particularly in the most impacted areas.

This study allows the utility to plan more accurately for the increased volume of customer and grid-side upgrades and suggests a progressive need for increased material procurement and staffing during the 2030-2050 period.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 2-284-24_Kostic_Pres.pdf