Search eceee proceedings
Health framings of meat consumption: experimental insights into policy acceptability in three European countries
Panel: 2. Future and innovative policies
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Abigail Alexander-Haw, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research, Germany
Joachim Schleich, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research, Germany
Josephine Tröger, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research, Germany
Abstract
Reducing meat consumption offers dual benefits for both climate and health, aligning with sufficiency lifestyles discussed for mitigating climate change. While individuals often decrease meat consumption upon learning about its health effects, little is known about how health-related information influences the acceptability of meat reduction policies. Our research aims to help fill this gap.
To this end, we conducted a demographically representative survey among more than 2,000 adult individuals in France, Italy, and Latvia in October 2023. The survey elicited individuals' acceptability of various meat reduction policies, with a randomised nudge regarding the health risks associated with meat consumption. The policies included carbon labelling on food products, a 10% meat tax, and a meat-free day per week in public and private canteens.
Our preliminary findings from multivariate analyses indicate that the health-risk nudge causally increases the acceptability of the meat taxes in Italy, and a meat-free day in Latvia, i.e., the more coercive policies compared to the labelling. Furthermore, heterogeneity models reveal that the health-risk nudge exerts varying effects on different subgroups of the population. In France, the health-risk nudge results in a higher increase in policy acceptability for a meat tax for respondents who experienced food deprivation compared to those who did not. Moreover, in Latvia, female respondents who received the health-risk nudge have a higher probability of considering the meat-free day acceptable than males who received the health-risk nudge. In Italy, respondents without an academic degree who received the health-risk nudge are more likely to find both the meat tax and meat-free day acceptable compared to those with an academic degree who received the same nudge. Further, we find correlational evidence that acceptability of policies is generally higher for policies which are deemed more effective, fairer, and less expensive, ceteris paribus. In addition, meat taxes are the least accepted policy in all countries while in France and Latvia (but not in Italy), meat-free days enjoy a higher acceptability than carbon labels. Finally, we find little evidence that age, gender, income and education levels are generally related with policy acceptability in our study.
Our findings also have implications for policy-making. Health-risk nudges can be effective in increasing policy support for more coercive policies, although the effects differ by country, highlighting the importance of considering socio-cultural factors in policy design. Moreover, recognising the heterogeneous effects of the health-risk nudge suggests the potential for targeted interventions aimed at specific subgroups to enhance policy acceptability.
Downloads
Download this display as pdf: 2-157-24_Alexander-Haw_display.pdf














