Search eceee proceedings

Nordic support policy for high energy costs: distributional and environmental impacts

Panel: 2. Future and innovative policies

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Alexander Eriksson, Anthesis AB, Sweden
Erik Gråd, Anthesis AB, Sweden

Abstract

During the winters of 2021-2022 and 2022-2023, European households and firms faced unprecedentedly high prices of energy. European governments responded swiftly, implementing support policies to address the burdens of high energy costs. In this study, we evaluate support policies in the Nordic countries, examining their distributional effects and environmental impact.

We initially surveyed policies targeted at reducing costs for electricity and transport fuels, for households as well as for companies. We included financial support (direct monetary transfers), price support (such as electricity tax reductions), and other policy types (such as payment deferral schemes or informational campaigns). Ten policies were selected: three each in Sweden and Norway, and two each in Finland and Denmark, covering the most important policies in terms of budget and likely impact. The reported empirical evidence for impacts of these policies is limited, so our analysis is mainly based on reasoning from other policy impact assessments and economic and psychology theory.

Most policies analysed did not effectively target the most vulnerable households and businesses. Policies were in general broad, compensating everyone. Monetary transfers were mostly based on either current or past energy use. This results in compensation that is higher for households and businesses with higher energy use. The same conclusion holds for policies directed at reducing prices, such as energy tax reductions.

Households in higher income groups tend to have higher energy expenditures, and thus received more support. In some countries, such as Sweden and Finland, households in the higher income groups also spend a higher share of their income on energy. Not only did high-income households then receive more support in absolute terms, but they also received more support relative to their income. In this sense, most support policies were regressive. A one-off payment to disadvantaged households in Denmark stands out as successfully targeting the most vulnerable households.

Environmental impacts depend on whether demand for energy is expected to increase following the policy implementation. When compensated for high costs, incentives to reduce energy use and increase energy efficiency are weakened. This goes in contrast to the EU principle of Energy Efficiency First and national goals of increased energy efficiency. Price support, such as reduced energy taxes have direct effects on demand. For monetary transfers based on energy use, how incentives are influenced depends on how the support is calculated, and how well households and businesses understand this process. Some support was based on current energy use. Other, such as the Swedish electricity support, was based on energy use during a past reference period. This allows compensation without hampering incentives for current energy savings and improvements in energy efficiency. However, communication around this faltered, and misunderstandings were common.

Ultimately, how incentives were influenced is an empirical question, for which our analysis provide no answer. Certain policy design features, however, risk creating expectations for future support, which undermines incentives for energy savings and increased energy efficiency.

Implementing support swiftly is believed to be a main reason for the chosen policy designs. In preparation for possible future periods of high costs, Nordic governments could consider policy design that make use of well-developed social security systems to create policies with more desirable distributional profiles. Even though such policy design should be possible, preparations may signal to consumers that support will be provided in times of energy shortage and high prices, weakening incentives for energy savings and increased energy efficiency. How to best balance these issues remains an open question.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 2-039-24_Grad_pres.pdf