Search eceee proceedings

Searching for energy savings quantifications for the Sufficiency Potential Database – like looking for a needle in a haystack

Panel: 2. Future and innovative policies

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Celia Burghardt, Wuppertal Institut for Climate Environment and Energy, Germany
Kaya Dünzen, Oeko-Institut, Germany
Jenny Kurwan, Wuppertal Institut, Germany
Benjamin Best, Wuppertal Institut, Germany
David Schöpf, Wuppertal Institut, Germany
Mirko Schäfer, University of Freiburg, Germany
Frauke Wiese, University of Flensburg, Germany
Carina Zell-Ziegler, Öko-Institut, Institute for Applied Ecology, Germany

Abstract

Reducing energy demand through sufficiency is necessary to achieve just and sustainable decarbonisation. Energy and climate scenarios therefore need to consider sufficiency in their decarbonisation pathways. However, to date, scenarios that consider sufficiency are very rare. Research has shown that modelers often lack quantified potentials of sufficiency measures, which they would need as input to energy system or sector models.

The aim of this paper is to fill this gap by providing an open access database with quantified energy savings potentials of sufficiency policies and measures for Germany. The database also includes existing quantifications of GHG savings from sufficiency policies and measures to demonstrate their potential.

To fill this database, we conducted a systematic literature review using Web of Science for peer-reviewed literature and Google Scholar for grey literature in English and German. We used the term "sufficiency" as well as a combination of the terms "absolute reduction"/"avoid" with terms such as "demand" or "consumption". After screening the 430 search results, only 14 of the papers and reports were found to contain relevant quantified sufficiency potentials. We added 35 papers known to the authors and provided by several sufficiency expert communities, so that the database is based on 49 literature sources quantifying sufficiency potentials for Germany.

This literature review shows that (1) there is literature on quantified sufficiency potentials for Germany. Most quantifications are found for the building sector. (2) The data is very diverse in terms of base year, time horizon and quantification method (simulation, evaluation, territorial vs. LCA view) and therefore not always easy to compare. Differences in reduction potentials also arise from the system in which the measures are quantified; for example, the energy saving from a reduction in living space is lower in a system with energy efficient buildings than in a system with a less efficient building stock. (3) The literature is not easy to find as the term sufficiency is often not used and searching for a combination of terms describing sufficiency leads to a lot of inappropriate results - it feels like looking for a needle in a haystack. Using literature known to the authors and expert networks to find appropriate literature was more helpful.

We conclude that our database, to be published later this year, is a first step to help modelers better account for sufficiency potentials in scenarios and to help policy makers understand the savings potential of sufficiency. We also call on researchers to further quantify the energy and GHG savings potential of sufficiency options to fill gaps identified.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 2-257-24_Burghardt_Pres.pdf