Search eceee proceedings
Taking new steps in the beyond growth debate: potentials and pitfalls of alternative economic concepts for the Netherlands
Panel: 2. Future and innovative policies
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Stephan Slingerland, TNO, The Netherlands
Stephan Slingerland, TNO, The Netherlands
Geerte Paradies, TNO, The Netherlands
Mauricio Rodriguez Acosta, TNO, The Netherlands
Eline Westbeek, TNO, The Netherlands
Abstract
In recent years a vivid public and academic debate has arisen about whether or not there is a need for more fundamental changes to our current economic system. In this ‘Beyond Growth’ debate many different alternative economic concepts are proposed. However, the exact implications of these concepts for future societies are still very unclear and the debate about them is blurred. In this project therefore eleven alternative economic concepts were selected, analysed and compared in detail. These are: ‘Green Growth’, ‘Mission Economy’, ‘Broader Welfare’, ‘Doughnut Economics’, ‘Degrowth’, ‘The Great Mindshift’, and ‘Buen Vivir’, and their Dutch counterparts ‘Green Growth NL’, ‘Broad Welfare NL’, ‘Post Growth NL’, and ‘Purpose Economy NL'.
For each of the concepts, viewpoints of the concept towards GDP, technological innovation, norms and value change and redistribution were examined. Furthermore, a theory of change assessment was performed for all concepts, analysing what final impacts each concept actually promises and which policy routes are indicated to get there. In this assessment, it was also investigated what implicit assumptions are underlying to the concept, what analysis of possible risks, drawbacks and side-effects is made, and how the concept describes its scaling mechanism. Finally, it was analysed to what extent current advanced modelling suites are capable of quantifying intended final impacts and policy routes of the concepts.
It was found that important distinguishing dimensions of the different concepts, next to their position towards GDP growth, are the degree to which they propagate change of current norms and values, as well as the degree to which they foresee direct governmental steering. Based on the different positions of concepts regarding these indicators, the concepts were divided into three main families and positioned towards each other in a taxonomy. It was also found that each of the economic concepts holds distinguishing possibilities for innovative policymaking and for new societal solutions, including e.g. ‘Moonshot Missions’ for Mission Economy, drastic working time reductions and inclusion of the caring economy for Degrowth, and a progressive consumption tax for Post Growth NL. However, it was also concluded that all concepts presently still show significant gaps in their proposed policy impact chains towards intended societal impacts and partly depend on underlying assumptions that are not yet fully underpinned by empirical evidence. This holds for instance for the supposed possibility of absolute decoupling of natural resource use from GDP growth in the Green Growth concept, or the presumed norms and values change towards more eco-centric attitudes in Degrowth. As for the possibility to model the impacts of alternative economic concepts, it was concluded that none of the models included in the analysis could quantify all distinctive features of the concepts. With a carefully selected suite of currently available models this should nevertheless be possible.
Overall, it was concluded that alternative economic concepts need further examination before they could be implemented in practice in the Netherlands. Four main routes were identified that could guide these efforts: to complete policy impact chains for all concepts; to analyse different scenarios of concept based on their distinct views on individual wellbeing and collective welfare; to quantify the potential impacts of the concepts and of individual innovative policy measures proposed by them; and to examine public support for policies that aim at influencing current norms and values. It is also suggested that broadening the current, mainly economy-centred public debate to the underlying normative questions regarding different societal definitions of our future welfare and the role of government in influencing our individual norms and values could lead to taking fundamentally new steps in a future Beyond Growth debate.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 2-138-24_Slingerland_Pres.pdf














