Search eceee proceedings
The crisis that made time-shifting normal: energy care and flexibility of Danish households during the energy crisis
Panel: 2. Future and innovative policies
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Kirsten Gram-Hanssen, BUILD Aalborg University, Denmark
Anders Rhiger Hansen, Aalborg University BUILD, Denmark
Line Valforff Madsen, Aalborg University BUILD, Denmark
Rikke Skovgaard Nielsen, Aalborg University BUILD, Denmark
Abstract
Time-shifting households’ energy-consuming practices from peaks towards periods with higher renewable energy production is an important factor in a sustainable energy system. Previous studies have shown that it is possible to get households to time-shift energy practices, but also that dynamic electricity tariffs until recently was not well-known. Furthermore, earlier studies on temporal energy consumption patterns did not reveal time-shifting of energy practices for a larger group of Danish households.
This paper shows how the energy crisis in Denmark during the winter 2022-2023 made time-shifting normal, and it asks the question of how to understand this process of normalisation. Following substantial energy price increases during 2022-2023, with strong fluctuations during a day and from day to day, energy was placed high on the agenda in politics and media. The paper seeks to understand to what degree care for the energy system was a driver for households to start time-shifting and follow energy prices. The paper is based on a quantitative survey (N=1000) and in-depth qualitative interviews (n=30). For both methods, there was a general focus on everyday practices and experiences related to the energy crisis.
The quantitative results showed that 63% indicated having flexible electricity prices, and among those, almost 70% indicated that they followed the prices daily. Furthermore, more than half of those indicating they had flexible prices used timers on washing machines and dish washers to plan appliance use. While there are some socio-economic variations, a factor which we call care for the energy system explains more of the variation in responses. The factor was created by combining responses on the following statements: I want to a) help Europe not having energy shortage; b) help my local energy systems to work more efficiently; c) help prevent a blackout; d) help to prevent climate change. Respondents scoring higher on this factor, tended more often to have flexible prices and time-shift their energy consumption. However, there are some variations regarding age. While the oldest part of the population (60+ years) time-shifted the most, they were not the ones having and using timers on appliances the most. Surprisingly, income and gender seemed to have less impact.
In contrast, the qualitative interviews indicated clear differences in time-shifting behaviour between affluent families and families with a tight economy. At the same time, differences were also apparent between people who were interested in and cared for the energy system and those who were not. For some households, time-shifting was thus a necessity to save money whereas for others it was like a game to see how much could be shifted based on an interest in caring for the energy and environment. Time-shifting included all types of consumption, also cooking and media-use, among the most vulnerable. Economy was mentioned by most respondents. However, when scrutinising this motivation, it was not based on rational economic calculations, and several respondents time-shifted without knowing exactly what type of tariff they had. Rather, they reported that they time-shifted because it was normal to do so and because they had heard much about the energy crisis and felt they had to do something.
The paper concludes that the energy crisis contributed to normalising time-shifting due to a combination of media discourse and governmental communication about caring for energy and being aware of actual energy prices. In relation to policy, this suggests that people can change practices, and that price can be an instrument in a sustainable transition but that media attention to and governmental directions on the need for change are needed as well. Also, price instruments are likely to have severe consequences for some households, which must be mitigated to avoid social imbalance.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 2-040-24_Gram-Hanssen_pres.pdf














