Search eceee proceedings

Credible and comprehensive? Comparing policy mixes for Local Energy Systems in England, Scotland and Wales

Panel: 3. Policy, finance and governance

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Janette Webb, University of Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Faye Wade, University of Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Jess Britton, University of Edinburgh, United Kingdom

Abstract

Definitions of Local Energy Systems (LES) in Britain encompass interconnected technical and social domains, with the expectation that local integration of heat, power and storage will make most efficient use of decentralised energy, reducing GHG emissions and whole system costs. British centralised energy systems however pre-date privatisation, and the value of, and routes to, integrated local energy remain contested. Governance and regulatory principles, business structures and finance are in flux. Devolved government however provides a natural experiment for research into varied political support for LES over time and between central (UK) and devolved Scottish and Welsh governments. This paper [1] asks: In what ways do emerging policy mixes for Local Energy Systems differ across Britain? What are the implications of any variation for likely effectiveness of LES policy?

Method

The paper develops and tests a policy mixes approach to examine differential LES policies in England, Scotland and Wales. A policy mix is conceptualised in terms of building blocks, including elements (policy strategy and instruments) and characteristics (qualities and performance) [2]. Policy mixes are evaluated using two characteristics: credibility (whether a policy mix is believable and reliable) and comprehensiveness (the extent to which a policy mix addresses all market, system and institutional failures).

Credibility was evaluated using policy duration, long term target-setting, managing organisation and budget. Comprehensiveness was evaluated first by calculating balance, defined as the dispersion of policy across instrument types, and second according to specificity (whether instruments focus on a technology, a sector or whole economy).

Analysis encompassed 105 policy instruments introduced by UK, Scottish and Welsh Governments between 2010 – 2021. Relevant instruments were identified through publicly available overarching energy strategies, alongside strategies specifically concerned with ‘local’, ‘community’ or ‘area-based’ energy.

Results

The number of policy instruments relevant to LES across England, Scotland and Wales has significantly increased since 2010, and all three jurisdictions have a highly diverse instrument mix (balance).

In England the policy mix is characterised by fluctuation and short-termism, including withdrawal of several instruments supporting community-scale renewables, making this the least credible. The mix of instrument types is however more comprehensive than in Scotland and Wales.

Strategies in Scotland and Wales demonstrate a more credible and ambitious policy mix, including long-term policies and new instruments added over time. However, constrained political powers result in less comprehensive policy mixes than in England. Prospects for realisation of LES in the devolved jurisdictions of Scotland and Wales are hence uncertain.

Conclusion

The paper highlights strengths and weaknesses of the policy mixes concept as an analytical tool for exploring policy divergence in devolved governments. Analysis demonstrates that distinct approaches to LES are possible in devolved policy systems. However, none of the policies are designed to challenge systemic interdependencies of GB’s liberalised and largely centralised energy system. Ultimately this limits capacity for developing integrated LES and highlights the need for regulatory and institutional innovation in policy, in GB and elsewhere, to realise envisaged energy, cost and GHG savings and socio-economic benefits.

Reference

[1] Wade F, Webb J & Britton J (2024) Credible and comprehensive? Comparing policy mixes for Local Energy Systems in England, Scotland and Wales, Energy Research & Social Science, 110.

[2] Rogge, KS & Reichardt K (2016) Policy mixes for sustainability transitions: an extended concept and framework for analysis, Research Policy 45(8):1620–1635.

Downloads

Download this display as pdf: 3-021-24_Webb_display.pdf