Search eceee proceedings

Effect of energy prices on the energy requirement and wellbeing of households

Panel: 3. Policy, finance and governance

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Kees Vringer, PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, The Netherlands
Astrid L. Martens, PBL, Environmental Assessment Agency, The Netherlands
Daan P. van Soest, Tilburg University, The Netherlands
Malik Çürük, Tilburg University, The Netherlands

Abstract

Reducing residential energy consumption is a key component of any country’s strategy to meet the greenhouse gas emission reduction obligations as agreed upon in the Paris Agreement. Surprisingly little is known about the impact of energy taxes on the amount of gas and electricity consumed, and on the distributional effects thereof. The fallout of the Russian invasion in Ukraine in March 2022 caused in the early summer of 2022 a strong, unexpected increase in the residential prices of both gas and electricity in the Netherlands, with a peak in November 2022. The price rise was expected to be long lasting, which makes the households’ behavioral response likely to be predictive of their response to the introduction of a large energy tax.

Our research questions are (a) how affects a large, unexpected and presumably long-lasting increase in the energy price the residential energy consumption?, (b) How did households experience the price increase and in what way did they change their energy behavior? Answering these questions will help policy to find an optimal tax rate to obtain reduction in households’ CO2 emissions and also shed light on the distributional consequences of these taxes.

To answer these research questions we gathered two types of data. First, we obtained individual energy and contract data of about 40.000 households. We focus on the subset of households with energy contracts with fixed prices; changes in the market price of energy do not affect the prices paid by households until after their fixed-price contract expired. The remaining duration of the contract is quasi-random at the time of the price increase and the households with fixed prices throughout the sample period can serve as a control group for those with a renewed contract. We analyzed these data with a dif-in-dif analysis. Second, we gathered questionnaire data from about 1600 households on three different occasions between November 2022 and November 2023. Respondents were asked questions on their energy behavior and changes therein, and about energy literacy and energy price perceptions.

We find that the price elasticity of natural gas demand is about -0.15 for changes about 70 percent while the short and medium-run demand elasticity strongly correlate with the size of price shock tending to a very low -6.2 percent for the largest price increases (320%) in our sample. Price elasticity was thus lower for very high price increases, suggesting a ceiling effect in behavior change. The reduction in natural gas demand appears to be persistent. Effects were similar for different income groups. Households anticipated higher gas prices by reducing their gas use even before their contracts ended and prices increased. In addition, longitudinal questionnaire data shows only small changes in self-reported behavior between November 2022 and November 2023, such as self-reported thermostat temperature settings. We did not find a change in energy literacy over time. The share of households that reported having great difficulty paying their energy bills gradually decreased during this period. In summary, the large price increases led to a persistent decrease in household energy demand.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 3-062-24_Vringer_Pres.pdf