Search eceee proceedings

International policy responses to the energy crisis triggered by the Russian invasion of Ukraine: A global comparison of best practices

Panel: 3. Policy, finance and governance

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Regina Betz, Center for Energy and the Environment / Zurich University of Applied Sciences (ZHAW), Switzerland
Tetiana Kurbatova, Sumy State University, Ukraine

Abstract

The invasion of Ukraine by Russia in 2022 triggered a major energy crisis as it became highly uncertain how much gas and oil would be delivered to European countries in the short term and the exact impact of the invasion and sanctions in the medium and long term. These developments had and have repercussions not only on the European energy market but globally.

High and volatile energy prices impose a burden on households and businesses dependent on these fossil fuels. Supply shortfalls pose a systemic risk for many economies threatening economic and social welfare. In addition, substituting away from fossil fuels takes time and investment therefore, a large part of households and businesses will still be dependent on these energy sources for electricity, heating and transport in the medium term.

In order to address these challenges and lighten the burden on businesses (not least to prevent potential political unrest) governments in Europe and around the world responded with a range of emergency measures. While there are similar measures undertaken to combat the crisis like government campaigns to the general public to save energy, there have also been unique measures by individual countries, which can be explained by the scale of their dependency on Russian gas and oil and the status of electricity market liberalization in the country.

The aim of this paper is to compare data on the exposure of countries and their policy measures taken to combat the energy crisis triggered by the Russian invasion of Ukraine. By clustering the countries according to their dependency on Russian fossil fuels and electricity price impacts, we want to find out if countries within the same cluster take similar response measures, thus teasing out which characteristics may determine certain response measures and what do they mean for the decarbonization strategies of countries. We differentiate between measures on the supply and demand side as well as between long-term and short-term as well as regret and no-regret measures from a decarbonization perspective. The latter are for example those measures aimed at reducing fossil energy consumption and increasing energy efficiency as well as diversifying away from imports, as these types of measures have the potential to sustainably address both the energy and climate crises in the long term.

Data to cluster countries according to their exposure to the energy crisis is collected from different statistical data sources such as EUROSTAT as well as from country experts. This data forms the basis for clustering the countries according to factors like gas imports and share of Russian gas imports, gas in the electricity mix, share of gas or electricity in heating. The information on the emergency measures introduced by EU countries is based on the Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER) dashboard, as well as information from country experts. Additionally, submitted country information by expert interviews provide data for countries outside the European Union.

We find that measures are mostly adapted to the specific situation of a country (e.g., market structure, gas import dependency, gas share in the electricity mix, gas share in heating). Almost all countries took short-term measures by introducing electricity price caps, lowered the VAT on energy prices or provided subsidies, which were often financed by a windfall profit tax on the excess profits from the sale of electricity and gas by utilities. The reduction of electricity and gas prices in comparison to the real scarcity may have been counterproductive as incentives for energy savings and efficiency investments are reduced. Finally, many countries did also invest in new fossil fuel infrastructure such as LNG-terminals. As a result, a lot of money was distributed, but little was achieved for the long-term net-zero transformation.

Downloads