Search eceee proceedings

Thirty years of European Energy Services Companies and Energy Performance Contracting: what we have achieved and what is the current Status?

Panel: 3. Policy, finance and governance

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Paolo Bertoldi, European Commission, Joint Research Centre (JRC) Ispra, Italy
Sergi Moles Grueso
Benigna Boza-Kiss, IIASA, Austria

Abstract

In order to reach climate neutrality by 2050, recent EU policy developments aim to mobilise public and private finance for the energy system transition. Energy service companies (ESCOs) are private-sector market players that have a potential to contribute to energy saving goals and channel private finance into energy effciency projects. In particular ESCOs through the implementation of Energy Performance Contracting (EnPC) are a solution to address investment gaps hindering the energy efficiency, building performance, and decarbonization goals. EnPCs not only mobilize private sector resources but also offer energy-saving guarantees, mitigating financial risks for both clients and providers.

Although ESCOs have been present in Europe since the 1970s there were not recognised as a key player in the implementation of energy efficiency. Only with the 1992 SAVE Directive their role was recognised in EU energy efficiency policies. Since then, there has been an overall increasing support from the EU and Member States first, with the Energy Saving Directive in 2006 and then with the Energy Efficiency Directive in 2012.

The European Commission JRC has carried out market research assessing the ESCO market size, the type, size, projects and the barriers preventing ESCO to fully exploit the economic energy savings potential. Drawing on data from national expert and stakeholder surveys in 2005, 2012, 2017, 2000 and 2022, the article presents the most complete information and assessment about the last thirty years of ESCO market developments, with focus on the period 2005 to 2022.

The authors have identified four types of ESCO national developments. In the “successful” markets, a strong and typically large ESCO market was present throughout most of the last 17 years. These markets include DE, UK, AT, FR and to a lesser extent IT and ES. In the “adventurous” markets, the role and strength of the ESCO/EnPC market was fluctuating over time, depending on the changing policy environment, which affected the overall market development (CZ, BE, SI, DK, SE, SK, HU, PL). The “small” markets, which have some ESCOs for specific projects, but has not been seen a significant roll-out (BG, RO, PT, IE, FI, NL, LV, HR). Finally, the “no-go” markets, have intended to kick-start the ESCO markets, but not yet succeeded after repeated trials (EL, LU, EE, LT, CY, MT).

The author assessed the conditions (e.g. policies, financing, trust, facilitators, etc.) that facilitated or hindered the markets and therefore determined the characteristics of ESCO national markets. While ESCOs’ activities initially focused on short payback projects in buildings and public lighting, more recently the policy focus is on ESCOs contributing to societal benefits of energy and carbon savings, increasing deeper renovation of buildings and renewable energy.

One special focus of the JRC reports has been EnPC projects in the public sector, which initially focused on buildings light renovation and public lighting, but recently showing a growing trend towards deeper renovations, integrating renewables, storage and flexibility and district heating. Projects have also been implemented in larger residential buildings (e.g. social housing) and in the industry sector.

Member States shall implement EU directives, particularly with focus on financing and renovation of buildings. Addressing current challenges requires market intelligence, technical support, and sector-specific qualifications, alongside the retargeting of public funds towards projects with longer returns, while leveraging private financing for the other interventions. The EU strategic directions, coupled with technical assistance, play pivotal roles as market drivers. The rightness/value of supporting ESCO markets through public policy or financial benefits has been often on the table for debate. The role of ESCOs in the energy efficiency arena, as well as in the building sector renovation targets is still strongly advocated.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 3-337-24_Bertoldi_pres.pdf