Search eceee proceedings

What makes the Dutch neighbourhood approach to become natural gas-free acceptable? An assessment of citizen’s perceived legitimacy on climate neutral building policies

Panel: 3. Policy, finance and governance

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Caren Herbstritt, Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, The Netherlands
Astrid Martens, PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, The Netherlands
Jarry Porsius, PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, The Netherlands
Kees Vringer, PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, The Netherlands

Abstract

Combating climate change requires major changes in the built environment. According to the national Dutch climate agreement all homes have to be heated without natural gas by 2050. The national government chose a neighbourhood approach, mandating municipalities to issue gas-free policy strategies for the local heat transition. Implementing this local approach firmly intervenes in citizens' immediate living environment. In a democratic system, the implementation of such strategies relies on the acceptance of the population. Therefore, it is important to better understand which policy characteristics affect citizens’ perceived legitimacy. We present the results of a study on the perceived legitimacy of policy choices to opt out of natural-gas heating of Dutch buildings.

We used a mixed methods approach on a representative sample of Dutch citizens (n= 2034), to collect data through a survey and a vignette study to analyse the factors that may affect the perceived input-, process- and output legitimacy. We used 5 focus group interviews to get a better view on the reasons why policy characteristics are perceived as being more or less important.

We observed a broadly shared feeling of poor representation and distrust in government, which affected respondents’ judgment. Dutch citizens are positive about the idea of gas-free heating, but skeptical about the policy plans. When carrying out current policy plans, we find that the chance of public resistance is high. Citizens are more likely to see policies as legitimate if costs are redistributed through the government and district heating infrastructures are publicly owned. Citizens want to be heard and their concerns taken into account, although to different degrees of participation and involvement. The existence of large uncertainties about local technological choices, investment costs and long-term end-user tariffs is a challenge in the process. Citizens value upfront certainty and equity across neighbourhoods when it comes to cost and changing to a new heating system.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 3-020-24_Herbstritt_Pres.pdf