Search eceee proceedings
Crowd sourcing data collection for effective appliance policy – the case study of air conditioners in Indonesia
Panel: 4. Monitoring and evaluation
This is a peer-reviewed paper.
Authors:
Fiona Brocklehurst, Ballarat Consulting, United Kingdom
Clara CAMARASA, IEA, France
Abstract
One of the challenges of making effective policies for appliances (for example Minimum Energy Performance Standards, MEPS) is getting access to up-to-date market data. Mandatory energy labels provide information on the energy efficiency and other features (such as size or capacity) of a product which is useful for policy makers as well as consumers. But collecting data on a representative sample of the market from conventional sources – commercial providers or commissioned surveys – is slow and expensive. Web crawling is a newer method which is cheaper and quicker but has its own limitations. Crowd sourcing data digitally is another new approach which can supplement, or possibly replace these methods.
In this paper we compare data gathered on one product group, air conditioners, in one market, Indonesia, using different methods: web crawling, crowd sourcing and the government mandatory data registry. We find that crowd sourcing was able to collect energy and price data on many models and the results appeared to be generally consistent with those from the other sources. Further, data from web crawling and crowd sourcing both showed that there are many high efficiency models for sale at the same price as low efficiency models. This means that there is scope to tighten the MEPS without affecting low-income consumers (who might struggle to buy air conditioners which cost more initially even if they are cost effective over their lifetime).
We find that the big advantage of crowd sourcing, particularly in markets where online shops are less popular, is making data collection, including prices, at low cost. This extends their usefulness to policy evaluation and to assist with market surveillance, improving appliance policies in every stage of their life cycle.
Errata
The column headers in Table 2 have been corrected and some minor typos have been corrected throughout the paper. (2024-07-01)
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 4-247-24_Brocklehurst_Pres.pdf
Download this paper as pdf: 4-247-24_Brocklehurst_rev.pdf














