Search eceee proceedings
Integrating Multiple Benefits into the reporting on energy and climate policies – an illustrated conceptualisation
Panel: 4. Monitoring and evaluation
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Niklas Reinfandt, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research, Germany
Frederic Berger, Fraunhofer ISI, Germany
Barbara Schlomann, Fraunhofer ISI, Germany
Abstract
The EU Commission’s Fit-for-55 package has outlined the need for pathways to climate neutrality by mid-century to have a shot at complying with the 1.5°C target of the Paris Agreement. Energy Efficiency and Renewables appear as key strategies in such pathways, while the still in today’s energy systems predominant fossil fuels need to be phased out rapidly. Therefore, pathways reaching climate neutrality in the middle of the century, as compared to unsustainable pathways maintaining substantial amounts of fossil fuels, are now clearly in the spotlight. Nevertheless, two important questions require further analytical support:
• What speed of phasing out fossil fuels leads overall to the highest benefits? Can in particular higher shares of energy efficiency more quickly phase out fossil fuels for the benefit of societies and the environment?
• Are all pathways to climate neutrality equally rewarding to society as a whole or are there broader aspects to be taken into account, notably when it comes to the role of energy efficiency options, as compared to carbon-neutral supply options (such as renewable supply options)?
While the first question has been asked already for quite some time, the second question regarding a better differentiation between different carbon neutrality pathways is rather new. For the second question, the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) itself is not a differentiating criterion anymore, compared to scenarios with fossil fuels, as all pathways aim to achieve climate neutrality by mid-century. At the same time, other impacts such as land use, material uses, employment, or import dependence and energy security gain importance.
Therefore, to answer these questions, a broader view on Multiple Impacts (MI) (also known as Co-Benefits, non-energy Benefits) is necessary for an enlightened decision-making process regarding the choice between climate neutrality pathways, in intermediate target setting for 2030 and 2040 (or intermediate years), and for policy action and implementation.
At a political level, the increasing need to address these issues is reflected in the growing importance of the principle of "energy efficiency first" (EE1).
EE1st not only plays an important role in the European Commission's strategies, particularly in the European Green Deal, but is also increasingly anchored in EU legislation, including in the Governance Regulation ((EU) 2018/1999) and the Renewable Energy Directive ((EU) 2023/2413). However, the most important development came with the revised Energy Efficiency Directive (EU/2023/1791), which establishes the EE1st principle as an overarching policy and decision-making principle. Its Article 3 requires for all relevant policy, planning, and major energy-related investment decisions a “proper assessment of the wider benefits of energy efficiency solutions where appropriate, taking into account the entire life cycle and long-term perspective, system and cost efficiency, security of supply and quantification from the societal, health, economic and climate neutrality perspectives, sustainability and circular economy principles in transition to climate neutrality”. These MI are especially important since energy system costs alone are not a clear argument for EE1.
As a consequence, it is paramount to understand how to translate the EE1 principle into practice through the consideration of the different MI, how it can enable the perception of energy efficiency as a driver for other major policy objectives, such as secure and affordable energy supply and how to report them for this purpose. In addition, an accessible and realisable concept is necessary to support Member States complying with their obligation to report under this article and in the monitoring and verification of plans requested by the European Commission (e.g., National Energy and Climate Progress Plans).
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 4-084-24_Reinfandt_Pres.pdf














