Search eceee proceedings

Projections in hindsight for the buildings sector: understanding drivers for future policymaking

Panel: 4. Monitoring and evaluation

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Kelsey van Maris, VITO, Belgium
Annabel Vella, VITO/Energyville, Belgium
Nele Renders, VITO/Energyville, Belgium
Tom Dauwe, VITO/Energyville, Belgium
Sonia Quiroga Gomez, Universidad Complutense Madrid, Spain

Abstract

The number of energy and GHG scenarios in European countries has risen significantly in the past decades. Retrospective review of these projections is essential for ensuring their robustness for future policymaking. By comparing projections with actual data, this study aims to understand: (1) how past projections for 2005-2020 compare with energy balances and emission inventories reported for the same period, and (2) which drivers and parameters are essential in understanding uncertainty in projection scenarios.

This study is conducted within the scope of Horizon Europe project PATTERN, which provides guidance on retrospective comparative analysis within the climate and environment policy context. The guidance demonstrates how to increase knowledge transfer between ex-post and ex-ante evaluations. To illustrate the learnings of a comparative analysis, GHG emission scenarios and their underlying assumptions for Belgium and the Netherlands were analysed, focusing on scenarios developed for buildings in the residential and services sectors for the period 2000-2020.

The analysis is based on GHG and energy scenarios estimated for research and policymaking, including official reporting under the EU GHG emission Monitoring Mechanism, now known as the Governance Regulation. The policy background of the scenarios was compared against the actual evolution of energy efficiency and emission reduction policy in buildings in both countries. Similarly, the projection parameters were compared to actual data to assess the accuracy of the development of key parameters and their effect on GHG emissions. Through the application of the index decomposition method, the causes of deviations from ex-post data are explained in terms of activity (population or services value added), energy and emission intensity and weather effects.

Over the assessed period, the policy landscape in both countries strongly progressed towards lower energy and carbon intensive buildings. As shown by the European Environment Agency database for climate mitigation policies and measures, the number of measures increased from almost none in 2000, to a total of 48 and 33 measures by 2020 in Belgium and the Netherlands, respectively. This was highly steered by three key EU legislations: the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive, the Effort Sharing Directive and the Energy Efficiency Directive. National measures mainly cover regulatory instruments (for example, tightening minimum energy standards for new buildings), financial instruments (for example, Rational Energy Use subsidies for Belgian households and Sustainable Heat Subsidy for Dutch households), and information measures (for example, Energy Performance Certificates).

The growth in the type and number of policy instruments over the years is reflected in the 2005-2020 projections through continuous improvements in carbon and energy intensity of the buildings sector. These expected improvements materialised partially in actual energy consumption and related emissions, but improvements for energy intensity tend to be generally overestimated. The projections also show difficulty to reflect well external conditions, such as economic fluctuations (covid), rising temperatures (heating degree days) and even demographic growth (households), although being important drivers of historical trends. This becomes visible in the deviations of projections from actual levels of annual energy use and emissions.

On average, 2020 residential projections for these parameters deviated by around 6% and 12% for Belgium and the Netherlands, respectively. Furthermore, the analysis indicates that drivers in the services sector are generally less understood than in the residential sector, reflected by high variability between scenario outcomes. Findings of this ongoing analysis aim to better understand the impact and uncertainty of policy drivers and projection parameters to support future scenario development.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 4-089-24_vanMaris_Pres.pdf