Search eceee proceedings

When data doesn’t motivate: potentials and limitations of app-based feedback for sustainable energy consumption

Panel: 4. Monitoring and evaluation

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Devon Wemyss, ZHAW Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Switzerland
Francesca Cellina, University of Applied Sciences and Arts of Southern Switzerland
Evelyn Lobsiger, Zurich University of Applied Sciences
Pascal Kienast, Zurich University of Applied Sciences
Pasquale Granato, University of Applied Sciences and Arts of Southern Switzerland
Tiziano Gerosa, University of Applied Sciences and Arts of Southern Switzerland

Abstract

Feedback on energy consumption has been widely shown to have a relevant, if insufficient and non-persistent, impact and thus remains a foundational element of many behavioural and social practice interventions in buildings. Using sensors and smart meters, data collection has become cheaper and the resulting personalized feedback, frequently offered via apps or webportals, is timelier and more granular. We argue, however, that a technology-focused and data-driven approach does not address the motivations of a broader population.

Our critique is a result of a behavioural intervention where we co-designed a smartphone app for energy savings with household members, technology providers, and utilities (1). The app went beyond consumption feedback to include personalized goal setting, social interaction and gamification elements. Results after one year of app use by 220 households found approx. 5% energy savings, compared to a control group. In the first months after the intervention, the savings actually reached 11%, though they dropped to nearly zero nine months later. Survey responses show that savings mainly came from reducing indoor temperatures. Whereas other routines around showering and laundry appear not to have changed. This hints at the difficulty of shifting cultural conventions on cleanliness-related topics.

Surveys and online workshops with participants showed that the voluntary participants were particularly affine to data-driven solutions and were already implementing energy efficiency practices at home. They told us they were not interested in social interaction with other participants, but rather wished for even more detailed information on energy consumption feedback, which could hardly be provided under the current technology and regulatory framework. This coincides strongly with the “resource man” conception by Strengers (2) showing that this style of energy savings interventions remains most interesting to those already engaged with the topic.

To achieve more impact (maintaining savings over a longer period of time) and scale-up (beyond the highly-motivated users), we propose new approaches combining users and business to better capture the value of data. To move beyond conventional individual interventions can highlight the collective challenge of climate change mitigation, and thus interventions can attempt to be even more closely embedded with everyday lifestyle routines. For example, living lab participatory approaches involving public and private actors (e.g. cities, energy providers, technology installers, trade unions, NGOs, universities, political decision-makers.), as well as the households themselves, offer a setting to explicitly question and re-negotiate current social norms and conventions around household energy consuming routines. While long-term change will necessarily involve data collection as part of a corrective feedback process, the behaviour change has the chance to persist if held within a supportive environment where regulation, infrastructure, norms, and ultimately behaviour can adapt and align (3).

1. Wemyss D, Lobsiger-Kägi E, Jud S, Cellina F. Leveraging realities of saving energy at home: Contributions of co-design to behavioural interventions. Energy Research & Social Science. 2023 Oct 1;104:103258.

2. Strengers Y. Smart energy in everyday life: Are you designing for resource man? Interactions. 2014;21(4):24–31.

3. Wemyss D, Cellina F, Grieder M, Schlüter F. Looking beyond the hype: Conditions affecting the promise of behaviour change apps as social innovations for low-carbon transitions. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions. 2023 Jun 1;47:100702.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 4-307-24_Wemyss_Pres.pdf