Search eceee proceedings

An Eye-Catcher for more effective and inclusive resident participation in the heat transition

Panel: 5. Sustainable communities

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Renee Kooger, TNO, The Netherlands
Nicole de Koning, TNO
Cyril Tjahja, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam

Abstract

Different kinds of participation methods are used to involve residents in municipal heat transition plans. An important conclusion of a recent European study on existing participation tools and methods, is that participation tools often ignore the question of how residents themselves would like to be involved. Existing participation tools often make assumptions to what extent and in which manner residents want to provide their input. This does not always correspond to the way in which residents actually want to be involved. This can create a mismatch between the needs of residents and the efforts of a municipality to get residents involved. Previous research by TNO concluded that many municipalities have (very) few resources (time, money and capacity) to devote to resident participation. Moreover, some groups of residents (e.g. residents who experience a language barrier, young families and youths) are often not reached by more traditional research methods like in-depth interviews or questionnaires.

In order to effectively use existing resources for resident participation by municipalities, it is important that they are tailored to the participation needs of a diverse group of residents. Desk research and focus groups with experts on resident participation confirmed that there is currently no instrument which municipalities can use to determine if, to what extent and in what way different types of residents want to be involved in the heat transition. TNO has therefore developed a practical and creative tool called the ‘’Blikvanger’’ (Eye-catcher). This is a tailor-made wooden object which can be placed in proximity of the target group (at a school, mosque, grocery store etc.).

The tool uses several interactive objects such as selecting smileys and placing magnets to gather information in a fun and different matter. The Eye-catcher has twice been piloted. Once in the municipality of Wierden, were it was used as part of an "energy fun fair". The municipality wanted input of a diverse resident group on the local heat transition plans. The energy fun fair was set up at a busy spot near a shopping center and contained different objects. Besides the Eye-catcher these included e.g. a wheel of fortune were residents could win sustainable prices, a smoothie bike were residents could cycle and produce a smoothie at the same time, activities for young children like drawing and face painting. Residents would be attracted to the different fun elements of the energy fun fair and could be approached to answer the questions on the Eye-Catcher. These included different questions which were drafted together with the municipality. 1) how do you feel about transitioning towards a more sustainable home? Residents would select a smiley ranging from a (very) unhappy smiley to a (very) happy smiley.

Residents were asked to elaborate on their choice. 2) What do you need for this transition? Residents could then flip different signs with suggestions like: financial support, communication and knowledge/advice. 3) what do you want to do together with other residents and the municipality? Here residents could place a green or red magnet at the different answering options e.g. "I want to join a fix team", "I want to buy insulation measures with my neighbors". 4) Do you talk to your neighbors/friends about sustainability? And if you do, what topics do you talk about? This was an open question were an answer could be filled in on a piece of whiteboard. Lastly, the residents could leave their 'signature' by placing their hand in a piece pin art.

All the questions on on the Eye-catcher including the name/title that is featured on the tool can be adapted to the needs of the user of the tool. In a different pilot the Eye-catcher was set up at a conference where the tool was used to gather input from municipalities on a proposed method that TNO was developing. At the ECEEE summer study the tool will be presented and will be used in practice.

Downloads

Download this display as pdf: 5-316-24_Kooger-display.pdf