Search eceee proceedings
Conceptualisations of energy and stakeholder expectations of households in an energy community
Panel: 5. Sustainable communities
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Sofie Nyström, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden
Cecilia Katzeff, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden
Miriam Börjesson Rivera, Uppsala University, Sweden
Abstract
Energy communities (EC) have been suggested by the EU as a way of making a clean energy transition by increasing the production of renewable energy while also empowering citizens to participate in their local energy system. This is seen as a critical step in decentralizing the energy system in a democratic way, treating households as energy citizens rather than consumers. The concept can be realized in many different forms such as local organisations, and cooperatives. In Europe, there are examples of energy communities where energy is locally produced, shared, stored, and consumed. In Sweden the number of such ECs is still small, mainly due to unclear legal requirements. Sweden has historically been privileged with an abundance of centrally produced inexpensive electricity from hydro and nuclear power. The power grid is owned by municipal or national companies, where the role of citizens is to be a passive end point, which purchases (and sometimes sells) electricity. This leads to a centralized perspective of electricity where citizens are stuck in the position of individual consumers, rather than part of a collective participating in the energy system.
Our contribution argues that this established framing of households may constitute a barrier for the development of energy communities in Sweden. Another potential barrier is treating energy as a commodity rather than an ecological resource or a social necessity. In this contribution, we describe preliminary results from interviews with stakeholders in the formation of energy communities in Sweden, focusing on expectations of households and the conceptualization of energy. Our contribution describes one case in the development of energy communities in Sweden. In this case housing cooperatives (HC) are recruited to form a local energy community through energy efficiency measures and, eventually, expanding to increased local energy production and virtually sharing electricity. Our interview study covers stakeholders that were part of initiating and forming the energy community, from early planning stages to practical implementation.
We see two examples that illustrate the ambiguity of how energy is conceptualized and the role of households in the EC. First, we observe a conflict between environmental and economic values. The EC is on the one hand argued to be an important step towards breaking the dependence on fossil fuels by providing local renewable forms of energy, mainly from PV panels and geothermal heating pumps. Stakeholders also describe how their own engagement with the EC stems from climate anxiety. This indicates that energy is primarily viewed as an ecological resource requiring careful conservation.
However, when describing the practical implementations of the energy community and the reasons for joining it, economic reasons dominate the reasoning such as participating in local flexibility markets and saving money. Our second finding is that agency is shifted from a citizen level to housing cooperatives and their representatives. For instance, housing cooperatives have made decisions regarding the timing of EV charging without prior information to residents. Representatives of the EC emphasise that the structure is one of ‘representative democracy’ where people assigned as ‘energy responsible’ are mandated by HCs to make decisions on behalf of their buildings, for example to decide when electric loads such as heating pumps and ventilation can be shut off between certain hours.
The general principle seems to be that being part of an EC is not supposed to affect households in any way, their role is mainly a passive one not to be disturbed. To conclude, the observed case represents a form of semi-decentralised EC where middle-out actors such as housing cooperatives are the decision makers on behalf of individual consumers. Different framings of energy carry different weight, where energy as a commodity continues to be the dominant representation.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 5-221-24_Nystrom_Pres.pdf














