Search eceee proceedings
Launching into the unknown: citizen views on citizen participation for municipal hydrogen projects
Panel: 5. Sustainable communities
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Sophie Lohmann, IREES, Germany
Karin Schakib-Ekbatan, IREES, Germany
Abstract
Citizens are a crucial stakeholder group for the energy transition, especially in urban communities where residents are more likely to live close to new energy infrastructure. Hydrogen presents a special case here: In contrast to PV or wind turbines, the public has so far had nearly no exposure to or experience with hydrogen technologies. Knowledge is therefore low and it is unclear how this affects willingness to participate as citizen stakeholders.
To answer this question, a pre-registered random mailing survey was conducted in three German cities in which green hydrogen projects are currently being planned or built. It assessed citizen knowledge about green hydrogen, willingness to engage in citizen participation, and local acceptance of hydrogen infrastructure projects (electrolyzers, refueling stations, and/or pipelines, depending on city). The data are based on a mixed-mode (online/paper) sample with mailing addresses randomly drawn from municipal registers. N = 166 residents from the three cities make up the final sample. On average, they were M = 47.52, SD = 17.89 years old and 54% male. Unless indicated otherwise, all items were measured on 5-point scales.
As expected, nearly everyone (99.9%, or all but two people) had heard of hydrogen, but few had in-depth knowledge, M = 2.96, SD = 0.89. Surprisingly, level of education was unrelated to how much respondents knew about hydrogen – the only demographic predictor was gender such that men reported knowing more about hydrogen than women did.
Most people had not yet heard about the hydrogen project in their city, although this differed by how advanced the project in their city was (12%, 25%, and 60% had heard about it, depending on city). This low project awareness is perhaps why people thought citizen participation was only of medium importance for this hydrogen project, M = 3.72, SD = 1.10. If citizen participation events were offered in the future, 60% said they would be willing to participate. This intention was unrelated to how attached they felt to their community or how long they had lived in town and did not differ across the three cities.
Local acceptance was medium-high, M = 3.88, SD = 0.92, with 77% of respondents approving or strongly approving of the project. Respondents indicated not only how much they accepted the project, but also the extent toward which their answer would change under different circumstances (conditional acceptance). Using gray instead of green hydrogen was by far the most unpopular option: 77% of respondents indicated that their acceptance would decrease under those circumstances. Other conditions that would decrease acceptance were increased land use of the project or if hydrogen had to be transported on the roads using trucks. In contrast, acceptance would increase with various forms of participation: The strongest increases were associated with financial participation (48% indicated that their acceptance would increase if profits partially went into the municipal budget for social projects; 41% if profits were partially paid out to the citizens themselves). Non-financial, deliberative citizen participation in the form of consultations or co-decision-making would also increase acceptance, though to a lesser extent (31% said their acceptance would increase).
This project offers a snapshot of citizen views about hydrogen at the onset of the hydrogen economy: We collected the perspectives of citizens who overall know little about hydrogen and are often unaware of relevant projects in their hometown, but are already or will soon be affected by hydrogen developments in their region. There was a general willingness to accept local hydrogen projects, but this acceptance is conditional: Most importantly, hydrogen must be produced using renewable energy only and citizens, the municipality, or both have to be involved in the project through financial and/or deliberative participation to increase acceptability.
Downloads
Download this display as pdf: 5-105-24_Lohmann_display.pdf














