Search eceee proceedings

Cass 2024 What is an e-cargo bikable trip?

Panel: 6. Energy-efficient and low-carbon mobility and transport

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Noel Cass, Institute for Transport Studies, University of Leeds, United Kingdom

Abstract

E-micromobility and specifically e-bikes have great technical or theoretical potential for substituting car trips for climate change mitigation (Bourne et al. 2022), even or especially in under-researched non-urban areas (Behrendt et al. 2021; Philips et al. 2022, 2024). We know that a huge proportion of empirical car trips are short enough to be feasibly (especially electric) cyclable. In the 2022 UK National Travel Survey (DoT 2022), ~30% of all car trips were <=10 miles (16km). In addition, e-cargo bikes in particular can share key perceived benefits of cars that aid substitution potential (Riggs 2016). These include their ‘cargo function’ (Mattioli et al. 2016), capacity for carrying children as passengers (Carracedo & Mostofi 2022), and weather-proofing (Lopez et al. 2017, Faxér et al. 2018).

However, technical potential is necessary but not sufficient to achieve adoption and use. The real-world potential for substitution relies either on a household or individual being able to replace many, most or all of their regular car trips with e-cargo bike usage. Discovering to what extent this is true, and it what ways, under what conditions, for which households, individuals and geographies, remains an under-researched topic (Bourne et al. 2022), although reviews of research on e-cargo bikes (Carracedo & Mostofi 2022) investigate trip purposes and characteristics. Bjørnarå et al.’s (2019) three-month loans of e-bikes (with trailers) and longtail e-cargo bikes in Norway is the closest comparable study, although it focused on health impacts, while Faxér et al.’s (2018) study of weatherproof e-cargo bikes focuses on commuting/business uses.

Using travel diary and particularly interview data from 49 month-long household trials of e-cargo bikes, we compared the users’ actual usage and their reasons and explanations of use and non-use for (especially anticipated) trips. Before the trials, participants almost all expected to use the e-cargo bikes for shopping and carrying children, with many expecting to commute. They almost all expected to replace car journeys. At the end of the trials, participants explained why they did not use the e-cargo bikes as expected. Taking children, or grandchildren, e.g. for “fun trips”, was difficult because they did not like it or were unenthusiastic, there was no room to carry a pushchair, or the weather was bad. School runs were avoided as children were ‘too young’. Large food or supermarket shopping failed, because of not enough room, not being as easy as a bike and trailer, or shops being too close to bother. Using the bike at all was difficult for a too-busy father, was seen as too big, unsafe, and wobbling, or as not comfortable enough for long (e.g. 34 miles) trips. Another felt they over-estimated their cycling competence, and found it hard to use on the road. However, trips unexpectedly added to these routines included (including multi-modal) commutes, leisure, sport and visits. And ‘secondary’ male users frequently took over use from their female partners if they were perceived as too big. The most prolific users of the e-cargo bikes tended to share certain characteristics, too. In particular, they had flexible working arrangements, e.g. being able to chose when to work in the office, were keen or proficient cyclists already, and were committed to reducing car usage as a general principle or for environmental reasons. A small number of participants used the e-cargo bikes to substitute all their car usage, although some had a partner whose use of a car was non-negotiable – typically for longer commutes or work trips. Car abandoning and car-free households were in this group of prolific users.

These findings suggest that support, advice and free trial loans of e-cargo bikes could be targeted to e.g. 2-car households and those whose characteristics and regular car trips match those of our most prolific sample, to maximise the potential to reduce car trips.

Downloads