Search eceee proceedings
Double vulnerability of households: portraits of the energy and transport poor
Panel: 6. Energy-efficient and low-carbon mobility and transport
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Lilia Karpinska, Krakow University of Economics, Poland
Nelly Unger, Germany
Johanna Cludius, Germany
Abstract
Both climatic and new geopolitical risks have increased the pressure on EU Member States to reduce their dependence on fossil fuels. In this study we focus on households and explore two aspects of households’ fuel dependency: (i) energy poverty, which receives much attention from policymakers and academia, and (ii) transport poverty, which is under-studied in the current research. The study aims to conduct a comparative analysis of and provide new insights into profiles of energy- and transport-poor households in the EU. Our previous research about hidden energy poverty in Central and Eastern Europe reveals that energy-poor groups are characterised by extra floor area, dependent children, tenure status, or single-family living. In the present paper, we broaden the time horizon, geography, and scope to cover the issues of transport accessibility, and car mobility in all EU countries.
We rely on several waves of micro-level data from Eurostat’s EU-SILC to draw the portraits and track changes over time. Our vulnerability indicators include the inability to keep home warm, car ownership, income poverty and accessibility of public transport with emphasis on households inhabiting thinly populated areas. We consciously limited our energy poverty sample only to at-risk of poverty persons due to the subjective nature of the inability to keep home indicators. Similarly, people who cannot afford a car and live in remote places can be genuinely defined as the transport poor. The profiles are constructed based on a set of demographic and housing variables, such as gender, age, health, education, employment, household size and type, and dwelling type. We use partitioning around the medoids clustering procedure and apply robustness checks to obtain the optimal number of clusters. To track changes in time, we include the same 27 EU countries in both 2012 and 2022, such as Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czechia, Germany, Denmark, Estonia, Greece, Spain, Finland, France, Croatia, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Latvia, Malta, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Sweden, Slovenia, and Slovakia.
According to our results, the weighted sum of households in energy poverty, which is a combination of inability to keep home warm and at-risk of poverty indicators, in 2012 and 2022 were respectively 8,472,672 (4.8 %) and 6,622,172 (3.86%). Transport poverty, which is defined as unaffordability of a car and inhabiting rural areas, affected 4,320,926 (2.45%) and 2,096,882 (1.22%) households in the same examined years. Consequently, individuals suffering from energy and transport poverty simultaneously represented 772,612 (0.44%) and 405,336 (0.24%) of the sample.
The results show that retired people in bad health living alone in large single-family buildings are part of both energy- and transport-poor groups. Profiles of the transport poor also include households without dependent children represented by working men and women in good health, and low or secondary education. To better capture regional specificity of profiles, we divided our sample into four geographical sub-groups, Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), Western Europe (WE), Northern Europe (NE), and Southern Europe (SE). Interestingly, double vulnerability profiles in CEE are characterised by owners living in single-family buildings, having basic level of education and a different employment status, pointing at in-work poverty inter alia.
The profiles for double vulnerability in WE are similar to those in CEE with the striking exception that described individuals usually rent their home. In SE, the profiles of double vulnerability are characterised by living in large houses. A mixture of tenants and owners is identified in both NE and SE profiles as being doubly vulnerable to both energy and transport poverty. The composition of groups is relatively stable across years, hinting at the presence of distinct target groups common to all countries in specific regions.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 6-194-24_Karpinska_Pres.pdf














