Search eceee proceedings
The life cycle carbon emissions effects of household e-cargo bike ownership and use: evidence from three UK cities
Panel: 6. Energy-efficient and low-carbon mobility and transport
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Ian Philips, University of Leeds, United Kingdom
Christian Brand, University of Oxford, United Kingdom
Labib Azzouz, University of Oxford, United Kingdom
Jillian Anable, University of Leeds, United Kingdom
Abstract
E-cargo bikes show potential for energy demand reduction in household contexts (Carracedo and Mostofi, 2022): like standard e-bikes they have greater range than normal bicycles for day-to-day transport. They also have considerably greater capacity to carry children, shopping and other items than conventional bikes and e-bikes (though e-bike to e-cargo bike is a continuum rather than discreet categories) allowing them to replace previously car dependent trips. They are becoming popular in several EU nations, however domestic uptake in the UK whilst increasing is very low (Garidis, 2023).
We trialled e-cargo bikes with participants for 1 month (mimicking personal ownership) in provincial UK cities (Leeds, Brighton and Oxford) using a variety of e-cargo bike types. Via a survey we were able to compare general pre-trial travel habits and demographics of our participants and others in the neighbourhood.
Using travel diaries we establish a measure of the distance travelled and the mode substitution by the e-cargo bikes for each participant. It is well reported how travel diaries typically underreport and miss trips (Aschauer et al., 2021). Following this we estimate the lifecycle per km CO2 emissions of each e-cargo bike and the mode substituted. Initial estimates use emissions factors from the literature, but we illustrate how we can improve estimates using vehicle data gathered from participants. Additionally, we describe steps being taken to calibrate travel diary data using GPS trace data. We report the variation in emissions reduction and how our participants may be classified by city, bike type and socio-demographic characteristics.
Our participants were chosen with an (intended) selection bias for car owning (and multi car) households; the need to reduce the demand for car travel in the UK is well established (e.g. Barrett et al., 2022; Winkler et al., 2023) . Our recruitment and approach also takes the view that that no single technology is a panacea so may not work equally well for all people in all places.
Prior to taking part, on average our summer trial participants own more cars than other people in their neighbourhoods, and they use their cars more often. Trial participants achieved lifecycle CO2 emissions reductions through trip substitution, we also examine whether participants achieve a reduction in overall car use. Based on travel diaries, e-cargo bikes were used to substitute for car trips far more often than any other mode (Figure1).
Figure 1 Km substituted by mode during e-cargo bike trials
Using emissions factors from the literature and the travel diary data we get an initial estimate of a mean CO2 saving per person year of use 170kg. However, calibration with GPS traces will likely increase this figure and we discuss the reasons for this. There is considerable variation in use, substitution and carbon savings between individuals. Identifying common characteristics of the high carbon saving group within our trial participants may help to identify the places people and transport energy consumption segments where e-cargo bikes may make a considerable difference to transport energy demand.
Our paper contributes to better understanding of the fact that the net effects on mobility-related climate change emissions are complex and under-researched. Studies of e-cargo bike suitability for domestic contexts is also less researched than e-cargo bike freight applications and our paper makes a useful empirical contribution: data gathered in the context of specific places provides insights to place-based approaches to decarbonisation. Our focus on car owning households means our results may contribute to understanding whether e-cargo bikes may help reduce the demand from particular transport energy consumption segments.














