Search eceee proceedings

Vulnerability structures across the EU-27: Assessment of 17 transport and energy poverty indicators using EU-wide microdata

Panel: 6. Energy-efficient and low-carbon mobility and transport

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Nelly Unger, Oeko-Institut e.V., Germany
Johanna Cludius, Oeko-Institut e.V.
Viktoria Noka , Oeko-Institut e.V.
Katja Schumacher, Oeko-Institut e.V.

Abstract

Energy and transport poverty and vulnerability are central in the debate around many energy and climate policy issues and have gained firm hold in central EU directives and regulations, such as the Energy Efficiency Directive, the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive, and the Social Climate Fund (SCF) Regulation. For many purposes, both related to EU policy, but also to policy at the national level, national governments need to establish indicators for both energy and transport poverty and vulnerability, e.g. to report on in their NECPs and to include in their Social Climate Plans under the SCF. While a number of established energy poverty indicators exist at EU level, the discussion about transport poverty indicators in the EU is only just gaining traction.

The goal of our study is to identify "vulnerability structures" in the EU by providing a comparison of vulnerable groups across European borders. We do this by looking at a selection of ten “representative” Member States from different corners or the EU and studying vulnerability structures within and across these Member States by applying 17 indicators (some of them composite) for both energy and transport poverty, using both traditional indicators such as 2M, M/2, keep home warm and arrears on utility bills, as well as indicators on Forced Car Ownership (FCO) and availability and accessibility of public transport. We employ the microsimulation model SEEK-EU based on Eurostat microdata sets for HBS 2015 (inflated to 2022/23) and several waves of the EU-SILC. The number of households identified as vulnerable differs widely depending on the specific indicators applied. We find a high degree of heterogeneity within and between Member States, highlighting the different focus of each indicator.

For the transport poverty indicators, no clear pattern emerges when comparing results across European regions – we rather find country-specific effects. Between indicators, we observe a large range from 1 % to 43 % of households identified as vulnerable in the transport sector. For heating, the expenditure-based indicators show on average higher shares (up to 26 %) of vulnerable households than the self-reported indicators (1 %–32 %). We observe that self-reported indicators are particularly high in Southern Europe and in some Central and Eastern European countries. We also find that including an income threshold (in our case “at risk of poverty”) into the expenditure-based indicators, reduces the share of households identified as vulnerable considerable. Indicators without an income threshold may therefore overestimate the share of vulnerable households especially in high-income Member States.

When targeting policy measures at vulnerable households, it is important that households can prove they are in the vulnerable group and authorities can confirm this, e.g. through income tax statements or social security benefits. A “policy indicator” is therefore likely to be based on information on household income. We estimate being “at risk of poverty” as one possible policy indicator. This indicator identifies a higher share of vulnerable households compared to many other indicators in both sectors. This points to the fact that an indicator purely based on income is not able to take into account may of the other important drivers of vulnerability in transport and heating. Governments should therefore expand their ability to identify households based on other important drivers of vulnerability, e.g. the energy performance of the building of a household or a household’s access to essential services.

Based on the results on vulnerability patterns across the EU, we evaluate the means available to support vulnerable households, taking the SCF as an example. The amount of funding that will be available per vulnerable household in heating and transport is directly related to the indicator chosen to identify those households. The funding per household will be higher if the targeting is very concise and the group of recipients is small. The funding per vulnerable household can also be increased if additional, national resources are available to support vulnerable households in the context of the ETS-2. This is particularly important for those countries that are not identified as vulnerable according to the Social Climate Fund, i.e. most Northern and Western European countries. Making additional funds available to vulnerable households (e.g. from national auction proceeds) allows the funding of more households or of more impactful measures. In keeping with the ETS Directive, national auction proceeds can be used to this end. In many countries, national auction proceeds will dwarf funding from the SCF.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 6-158-24_Unger.pdf

Download this presentation as pdf: 6-158-24_Unger_Pres.pdf