Search eceee proceedings

Addressing the split-incentive dilemma: how to share heating costs fairly while maximising the incentive for both residents and housing associations to save energy

Panel: 7. Policies and programmes for better buildings

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Simon Moeller, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Germany

Abstract

One of the main problems for increasing energy efficiency investments in the existing building stock in Germany is the split incentive dilemma. Property owners, such as housing associations, have little incentive to invest in energy efficiency measures because mainly the tenants benefit from the reduction in energy costs. However, tenants will not invest unless it is their own property. Although there are currently regulations in place to address this dilemma, they often do not work as intended. Not only do renovation rates remain too low and energy demand in the existing stock too high, but refurbishments can also lead to social problems such as stronlgy increasing rents and a displacement of residents.

To address these issues, the current government in Germany has agreed to consider regulations where the rent includes heating costs (warm rental models). A major challenge for such models is how to increase the incentive for housing associations to invest in energy efficiency while maintaining a strong incentive for tenants to use energy sparingly, as required by the EU Energy Efficiency Directive 2012/27.

In a current research project, we are investigating different models. There are several issues to be addressed, such as how to share the responsibility for energy consumption between landlords (building structure and technologies) and tenants (comfort behaviour). Another question is how to deal with the problem of rebound effects in energy-efficient buildings and prebound effects (Sunnika-Blank & Galvin 2012) in old buildings, and make the change from the current system to a warm rent system socially acceptable, i.e. not to cause a sudden increase in costs for previously economical tenants. We make a conceptual proposal for a new warm rent model that addresses these issues. The research builds on living labs in residential buildings where we have investigated occupant-building interactions and how a fair and reliable distribution of heating costs could look like.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 7-245-24_Moeller_Pres.pdf