Search eceee proceedings
Carbon price or installation ban - decarbonising space heating in the EU
Panel: 7. Policies and programmes for better buildings
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Robin Hasse, Germany
Ricarda Rosemann, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research
Robert Pietzcker, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research
Gunnar Luderer, Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research
Abstract
Current sales of heating systems are still dominated by fossil fuel boilers. These new boilers could lock-in substantial future CO2 emissions due to their long lifetime, putting the decarbonisation of the residential sector at risk. Carbon pricing and an installation ban for fossil fuel boilers are among the most discussed policy instruments. Some member states (MS) have introduced carbon pricing instruments for heating fuels, but the coverage and the prices are mostly low. The EU-wide emission trading systems will not cover direct emissions in the building sector before 2027 and the future price levels are highly uncertain. The installation of new fossil heating systems is banned in some of the EU MS, but more than 70% of the current heating demand is not covered by phase-out policies.
In this study, we use the new building stock model BRICK to compare the effect of a strong implementation of either and both of these policy instruments on the decarbonisation of space heating in the EU. In one scenario, we set a carbon price on heating fuels of 150 €/tCO2 until 2030 rising linearly to 400 €/tCO2 in 2050. The second policy scenario prohibits the installation of coal and oil boilers after 2025 and of gas boilers after 2030. Electricity is assumed to reach zero emission intensity in 2035 and district heat in 2040. We compare the results to a policy scenario combining both instruments and a baseline scenario without policies to enforce heating decarbonisation and only minor emission intensity reduction of electricity and heat until 2050.
Preliminary results show that the stock development differs considerably between the two scenarios. The carbon price leads to an immediate and persistent switch towards clean heating technologies whereas the installation ban only takes effect after the effective date but then leads to a faster phase out of fossil fuel boilers.
In the scenario with carbon price, natural gas boilers remain an important technology in both new construction and the renovation of existing buildings but they lose their dominance in installation for the benefit of non-fossil technologies. Clean heating technologies serve more than 60% of the residential building stock in 2050.
Following the installation ban of fossil fuel boilers, the market of heating technologies drastically shifts and is dominated by heat pumps and district heating after the ban. Installed fossil fuel boilers phase-out as they reach the end of their technical life time but still make up 20% of the stock in 2050.
The carbon price scenario reaches an emission reduction of around 70% until 2050 compared to 2020. After new gas boilers are banned in 2030, the installation ban scenario is faster to reduce emissions cutting around 80% of 2020 emissions until 2050. Both policies combined can reduce the emissions even faster with a reduction of almost 90% within the same period. Only the sensitivity scenarios with shorter lived fossil fuel heating systems get close to full decarbonisation around 5% residual emissions in 2050 compared to 2020.
Our results seem to indicate that a high carbon price in 2030 and beyond leads to a switch towards clean heating technologies immediately as it increases the heating cost for all fossil fuel boilers in use. In the installation ban scenario, emission reductions only happen after the ban is implemented, but emissions then reach lower levels after 2040 compared to the carbon price scenario, as the ban completely rules out the installation of fossil boilers. Combining both policies leads to a comparable pace of emission reduction as the installation ban alone but takes effect immediately just like the carbon price alone and suppresses anticipatory effects before an installation ban. The fact that only sensitivity scenarios with shorter lived fossil fuel heating systems come close to full decarbonisation until 2050 might indicate an entry point for additional policies encouraging the exchange of very old fossil equipment.
Downloads
Download this presentation as pdf: 7-032-24_Hasse_Pres.pdf














