Search eceee proceedings

Energy performance certificates in Europe – their differences and why that matters

Panel: 7. Policies and programmes for better buildings

This is a peer-reviewed paper.

Authors:
Mahsa Sayfikar, Heriot-Watt University, United Kingdom
David Jenkins, Heriot-Watt University, United Kingdom

Abstract

The Energy Performance in Buildings Directive (EPBD) implies a level of harmonisation in how energy ratings are generated for buildings across Europe. However, whilst central tenets of standardisation and replication are seen across different countries, the details of how Energy Performance Certificates (EPCs) are calculated and applied vary considerably with geography. This has implications on how different assessors are trained, how those EPCs are (or should be) used in policy, and raises questions around whether EPC ratings from different countries are comparable.

The Horizon-funded crossCert project has the aim of highlighting these differences, and investigating what this means for “next generation” EPCs. As new innovations (e.g. metrics, consumer information, alternative methodologies) are being tested for upgrading EPCs, the ability to do this with equal effectiveness for all countries is questionable for such divergence of methods.

This paper reports on a cross-comparison of EPC methodologies, to ascertain differences in numerical outputs and subsequent recommendations for buildings. This provides a holistic overview of how EPC approaches differ, and where and why this might be important. Furthermore, with the project aiming to engage with a range of stakeholders who interact and/or use EPCs, the paper reports on a survey of different groups of end-users. The survey gauges the perceptions of various EPC users in the respective countries, focusing on the trustworthiness of the certificates and the information they provide. By collecting insights from users, the project aims to gain a holistic understanding of the perceived reliability of EPCs across different methodologies and form a foundation for next-generation EPCs.

The results suggest that, whilst there are similarities in some countries, significant differences in EPC frameworks produce very different interpretations of building energy efficiency depending on selection of EPC approach. Faced with such differences, the paper questions whether it is possible to design EPC innovations that are country-agnostic and stimulated purely by central, Europe-wide guidance. It is concluded that the different frameworks identified require tailored and country-specific treatment to ensure effective evolution of next-generation EPCs, such that they can accommodate new technologies and applications to different areas of zero-carbon policy. Finally, the paper discusses how the need of the user of EPCs should be a central part of this design process.

Downloads

Download this paper as pdf: 7-180-24_Sayfikar.pdf

Download this presentation as pdf: 7-180-24_Sayfikar_Pres.pdf