Search eceee proceedings

Integrating sufficiency policies in National Buildings Renovation Plans: an unmissable opportunity

Panel: 7. Policies and programmes for better buildings

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Laetitita Aumont, EEB European Environmental Bureau, Belgium

Abstract

The ECEEE Summer Study will take place a few months before the start of national implementation of the EPBD, which will include drafting National Building Renovation Plans (NBRPs ). Considering that sufficiency is an element to which the overview of implemented and planned policies and measures in the NBRPs may refer to, we would like to present our work on the potential of sufficiency measures in the built environment to tackle both the high environmental impact of the sector and the current housing crisis.

Although efficiency improvements and the increased use of renewables have reduced CO2 emissions in the use phase of residential buildings by 29% over the period of 1990-2018, because new construction has led to an increase in the living space per person (especially in the wealthiest countries), the energy demand per capita has remained rather stable. This ‘rebound effect’ clearly underlines that the EU cannot reach its objective of a climate neutral building stock without considering the implementation of sufficiency policies.

In addition, this session would also encompass how sufficiency policies can deliver a fair and just transition of the building sector, tackling current challenges such as rising cost of living, housing shortage, poor housing conditions, and growing homelessness. In 2021, 17% of the EU population lived in overcrowded households and 8.3% of the population was overburdened by housing cost. However, this does not solely reflect an insufficient number of buildings. In fact, most countries have a substantial number of vacant buildings. On average, 16% of European dwellings were not occupied in 2011, and 35% were underoccupied. This represents 30 million empty dwellings, and yet, 15 million new ones were built between 2011 and 2020.

Turning towards sufficiency measures in the built environment would allow national governments and local authorities to address environmental and social issues at the same time. To illustrate our point, we have gathered a number of best-case examples of implemented sufficiency measures and policies proposals related to the existing building stock (addressing issues of wrong-sized space, vacancy and misuse of existing space) and unbuilt land (addressing issues of inner-city densification and urban sprawl). We would like to emphasise that sufficiency measures do not only apply to the energy use of buildings but also to our consumption of water, land and materials when building new.

“The greenest building is the one already built”, particularly since reusing an existing building can reduce emissions by 50%-75% compared to an identical new-build. We argue that monitoring the use of the existing building stock would allow for better housing policies such as targeted fiscal measures and economic incentives for renovation and moving schemes, facilitated through a close collaboration with local authorities and the wider public. Finally, making use of the existing building stock by transforming unused office spaces into social housing for example, would also allow to avoid further inner-city densification or the sealing of unbuilt land and reduce urban sprawl.

We would provide the audience with concrete examples of where these measures were put into action. These will include public policies - such as taxing vacant housing based on potential rental income, already successfully implemented in France – but also functioning private initiatives that deserve upscaling. For instance, the renovation of unused offices spaces in Ireland, where a 7. 500 square meters office space was converted to 86 one- or two-bedrooms apartments, allowing for a 62% reduction of carbon emissions compared to a new build in a whole life carbon assessment and 82% reduction of embodied carbon. Finally, we will cover best-practice examples of financial support schemes, such as the German state-owned investment and development bank KfW supporting co-living projects through reduced interest rates.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 7-054-24_Aumont_Pres.pdf