Search eceee proceedings

Old and wise? How to combine smart new technologies with traditional solutions

Panel: 8. Products, systems and technologies to decarbonise buildings

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Author:
Noam Bergman, University of Sussex, United Kingdom

Abstract

We are currently undergoing two global transitions: digitalisation and decarbonisation. There are (often implicit) assumptions that digitalisation is both necessary for decarbonisation, and that it will inevitably catalyse the decarbonisation transition. Smart technologies promise to deliver clean energy when and where it’s needed, enable energy efficiency in all sectors, and maintain – or enhance – existing lifestyles while delivering economic growth.

However, while digitalisation can deliver energy savings in many areas, the current trajectory of the digital transition is focused on consumerism and enhancing growth. This could leading to higher energy use: First, directly, as digital technologies spread and require more electricity for new devices, data flow and data centres, and the high embodied energy (and emissions) from smart devices, appliances and infrastructure. And second, through a variety of rebound effects as newer smart devices carry the expectation of new services and functionalities, creating new demand.

Meanwhile, others question the ubiquity of smart solutions, from engineers calling for “excellent dumb cities”, to architects calling for “high science, low-tech” developments, and transport research calling for “low mobility” future transport systems. Many of these approaches call for making use of existing technologies alongside traditional knowledge and solutions, rather than rely on future, unproven developments.

This paper is a thought piece, considering what principles might guide us in combining new and old to ensure necessary energy savings and environmental impact reduction through rapid change, and questioning narratives relying on future technologies that lack engagement with complex behavioural and societal effects.

I draw on two approaches. The first is digital sufficiency, that considers what minimum level of digitalisation can deliver environmental benefits and social wellbeing, rather than pursuing maximal digitalisation in every sector [1,2]. Digital sufficiency enables to consider both energy and resource use of digitalisation versus alternatives, and societal impacts of ICT, including the wellbeing of users. It demands rethinking ICT from the design stage, with roles for communities, ICT developers and policymakers. Digital sufficiency could counter techno-optimism, allowing room for more traditional, less technology focused solutions.

The second is Max-Neef’s [3] needs theory, that distinguishes between fundamental human needs, satisfiers that can meet them, and artefacts that facilitate satisfying needs. Satisfiers and artefacts can be culturally specific. Applying this theory allows us to consider how ICT impacts quality of life, transcending the division of needs and wants. ICTs’ contribution to satisfying needs depends on how they are embedded in socio-technical systems. Research suggests that configurations of optimal need fulfilment, in line with environmental sustainability, align with reduced use of ICTs [4].

These two approaches together could help us consider digitalisation both as it impacts individual well-being and its potential to achieve broader societal goals including decarbonisation. By embedding digitalisation in a socio-technical system, behavioural and societal effects can be considered, and ICT impacts can be better compared to other ways of satisfying our needs.

1. Colaço, I. Digital Sufficiency as a Principle for Energy Transition Policies. Ökologisches Wirtschaften - Fachzeitschrift 36, (2021).

2. Santarius, T. et al. Digital sufficiency: conceptual considerations for ICTs on a finite planet. Ann. Telecommun. 78, 277–295 (2023).

3. Max-Neef, M. A. Human-scale development: Conception, application and further reflection. (1991).

4. Guillen-Royo, M. Applying the fundamental human needs approach to sustainable consumption corridors: participatory workshops involving information and communication technologies. Sustain. Sci. Pract. POLICY 16, 114–127 (2020).

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 8-164-24_Bergman_pres.pdf