Search eceee proceedings
Can green hot briquetted iron trading help steel decarbonization and achieve NDCs and the Paris agreement? Evidence from eleven countries
Panel: 9. Energy efficiency and sustainability of industry
This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.
Authors:
Zhenxi Li, Lund university, Sweden
Max Åhman, Lund university
Lars J Nilsson, Lund university
Jonas Algers, Lund university, Sweden
Abstract
The steel industry accounts for 7-9% of global greenhouse gas emissions. To meet the Paris agreement, the decarbonization of the steel industry is urgent. Most of the steel production nowadays is in Asia, who accounts for 73% of global steel production in 2022. The top eight Asian steel producers in 2022 are China, India, Japan, South Korae, China-Taiwan, Vietnam, Indonesia, and Malaysia. Their total steel production accounts for 99% of the total Asian steel production. Thus, their ambitions on steel decarbonization will hugely affect the CO2 reduction of the global steel industry. Even if all of those countries/region have announced their carbon neutral time in their Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs), between 2050-2070, none of them have detailed long-term climate target and plan for their steel industry.
Decarbonizing the steel industry in those countries/region is not easy since they already have have huge amount of blast furnace – basic oxygen furnace (BF-BOF) capacity which is carbon intensive. In addition, most of them have recently announced that they plan to invest heavily in new blast furnaces. To mitigate the CO2 emissions caused by producing BF-BOF steel, carbon capture and storage (CCS) may be an option. However, CCS has caused a lot of discussion that it is not an optimal choice to mitigate emissions.
One way to solve this problem is to import green Hot Briquetted Iron (HBI) from, for example, Australia, Brazil or South Africa –countries with large iron ore reserves and a large renewable electricity potential. No research systematically study how HBI trading can affect national steel production pathway for those Asian regions and how HBI trading can contribute on achieving NDCs and the Paris agreement. Here, we interpret the NDCs as the time of carbon neutrality and the Paris agreement as the cumulative CO2 emissions before carbon neutrality. In addition, none of them consider how HBI trading will affect the HBI exporters annually, from the perspective like annual green H2 consumption and job opportunity. In addition, no study focuses on emerging economic, like Vietnam, Indonesia and Malaysia who will be also emerging in steel capacity in the future.
Thus, we build a long-term cost minimal optimization model to study the steel production pathway of the eight Asian countries/region under the goal of achieving their own NDCs or the Paris agreement, and most importantly, the impacts of green HBI trading on both HBI importer (the top eight Asian steel producers) and exporters (Australia, Brazil, South Africa). Four scenarios are built, based on the presence or absence of HBI trading, the timeline for grid power decarbonization, and the strength of climate target. From there we assess how HBI trading and varying reduction ambitions on both the grid power and steel industry can affect: the total cost, CO2 emissions, future steel production pathway, directed reduced iron demand, green electricity and H2 demand, the risk of standard capital and employment opportunity. Finally, we end by discussing the geopolitical difficulties of doing HBI trading and giving associated policy recommendation.
Our main conclusions are: 1) HBI trading can reduce 5-10 Gt total cumulative CO2 emissions, but can not advance the carbon neutrality time: the neutrality of grid power is the key for when the steel industry can be carbon neutral. 2) HBI trading can lead to 2764 Mt less BF-BOF steel production and accelerate the phase out of BF-BOF steel capacity1-7 years earlier, but HBI trading can cause more standard capacity. 3) The best strategy for steel decarbonization in different countries/region is different. In China and south Korea, HBI trading is the most efficient way to reducing CO2. In India, setting stronger NDC is the most efficient way to reduce CO2 emissions; in Japan, Taiwan, Vietnam, Indonesia and Malaysia, the most efficient way is to decarbonize grid power as quick as possible.
Downloads
Download this display as pdf: 9-042-24_Zhenxi_display.pdf














