Search eceee proceedings

Decarbonising basic materials for buildings – exploring circular economy scenarios for the EU

Panel: 9. Energy efficiency and sustainability of industry

This is a non-peer reviewed extended abstract. No paper available.

Authors:
Meta Thurid Lotz, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research, Germany
Matthias Rehfeldt, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research ISI, Germany
Andrea Herbst, Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research, Germany

Abstract

In 2020, 6% of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in the European Union (EU) were caused by the production of construction materials including basic materials. To meet the climate targets, it may be necessary to reduce this basic material demand, given high production quantities and significant emission shares. However, the potential to reduce this demand is closely interlinked with the future development of the building stock. On the one hand, it could increase due to a rising demand for building-related services, such as comfortable living, education or workspace. On the other, it could be reduced by implementing circular economy strategies, such as designing and constructing buildings more efficiently, extending the lifetime of buildings or re-placing conventional construction materials. Consequently, a circular economy for buildings gains momentum for reducing basic material demand and contributing to achieve EU climate targets. However, the material demand for buildings cannot be completely avoided. Thus, it is necessary to analyse further options for decarbonizing the basic material production. Building on this research interest, this contribution aims to answer a two-part research question: (1) What is the potential impact of a circular economy in EU buildings on material demand and (2) how does a circular economy for EU buildings affect the decarbonization of basic material production in the industry sector?

To answer this question, we applied a stock-driven material flow model of steel, concrete, glass, insulation and wood in EU buildings. Within this model, we determined the potential impact of a circular economy in buildings on material demand for five scenarios: (1) Increased re-cycling focusing on activities that improve the reuse and recycling of building elements and building materials; (2) Material efficiency including activities to reduce material use by design and to reduce emissions-intensity of the used materials; (3) Demand reduction especially during the use of buildings by extending their lifetime and using space more efficiently; (4) Material substitution with timber for structural applications; (5) Mix of all above-mentioned activities.

Scenario 5 (Mix) was selected for analyzing the basic material production in the industry sector. For this, we applied the bottom-up model FORECAST, which simulates future GHG emissions and assesses industry transformation pathways. The tool aims to model the decarbonization of the industry sector based on techno-economic assumptions. It considers a broad range of GHG mitigation options like energy efficiency or switching to carbon neutral energy carriers and processes.

The results of the stock-driven material flow model show that all scenarios reduce the demand for the materials by up to 65% except for wood. The wood demand increases in scenario 4 (Material substitution) and 5 (Mix) by 207% and 83%, respectively – as it is used as a substitute for conventional, emission-intensive materials. Scenario 5 (Mix) achieves the highest reduction through an ambitious combination of all circular strategies. For instance, the concrete demand for EU buildings in 2050 is reduced by more than 160 megatons (-47%).

Overall, the decarbonization of basic material production in the industry sector in 2050 is achieved by using electricity as the main energy carrier followed by hydrogen. In this scenario, a circular economy for buildings primarily reduces energy and feed stock demand. Consequently, the demand for hydrogen is lower than in comparable industry decarbonization scenario – lowering costs for renewable energies, grid expansion and the import of secondary energy sources.

In conclusion, decarbonizing the basic material production for buildings is achievable and can be facilitated by a circular economy. Further research should investigate other products with high relevance in terms of basic material demand and circular economy potentials, such as vehicles or plastic products.

Downloads

Download this presentation as pdf: 9-016-24_Lotz_Pres.pdf